Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and radio host of KDKA-AM and 93.7 The Fan answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Amy: If the Steelers lose against the Bills, how would you rate this season? Is it a failure? Is it a success? How important is winning a playoff game this year? I have a hard time understanding how a playoff season can be a failure, but on the flip side, the Steelers haven’t won a playoff game in a long time and that used to be part of the standard. What do you think this game means to the Steelers and for Mike Tomlin?

Zeise: That is a great question. I believe you are a teacher, so let’s talk in your terms. As of right now, I have this season graded as a C. I think if the Steelers win Sunday, it goes to an A-minus. But if they lose Sunday, I think it will remain a C. I don’t think the Steelers should aspire to getting a C. I don’t think the Steelers should be happy with a seventh year in a row without a playoff win. Revisiting your question, the Steelers need to win this season or it is going to be just another disappointing season that is below the standard that has been established.

Advertise with us

John: Am I the only guy who gets queasy when Pressley Harvin III comes in the game? Really, he's the best they can find?

Zeise: No, based on my emails and social media interactions, I would say you are not the only one who gets a sick feeling in their stomach when he punts. My favorite is on the live in-game chat I do when he has a bad punt. There is an explosion of posts. And now that Matt Canada is gone and Mitch Trubisky has been benched, Harvin is definitely Steelers fan enemy No. 1. They have brought in some other punters over the last few years, but somehow, he keeps rising to the top of the depth chart. I have to believe this is his last season, but then again, he could be around for another decade at this rate.

Zach: Was the AFC North the best division in the NFL this season? Three of the four teams made the playoffs, and all four finished with winning records.

Zeise: I saw something that this was statistically the best division since 1935. This is the first time since that year that every team in a division finished with a winning record. So yes, this was definitely the best division this year, but historically, it is one of the best divisions ever. And for the record, it was NFL West and comprised of the Packers, Bears, Chicago Cardinals and Lions that all finished with a winning record in 1935.

Engstock: What do you make of Bill Belichick? Can you think of any coach as successful as he's been gone as badly as he has? Could it be that he was never a coaching genius aside from being smart enough to play Tom Brady? I think he's had something like three (?) winning seasons without Brady. Do you think he'll leave New England, and if so, where do you think he'll land?

Advertise with us

Zeise: I am getting the impression he is likely to survive in New England. And I think the reason is because the Patriots are not really that far away from being a force again. I think if they add a quarterback and a few weapons around him, they will be a tough team to deal with because the defense, Belichick’s forte, has been successfully rebuilt. Belichick is an all-timer, but like most coaches, he has proven it is hard to make the playoffs and win big without competent quarterback play.

Jason M: I heard you on the radio say you not only think the Steelers will cover the 10 points, but you put money on them to win. Did I hear this correctly? And if I did, to use your own phrases, are you smoking too much wacky tobaccy and sniffing too much glue? You can’t be serious, right?

Zeise: You heard me right. I think the Steelers will take advantage of Josh Allen mistakes and win the game. Sean McDermott is an overrated coach who makes bad decisions at the worst times. The Bills are a loser organization that always loses, usually in spectacular fashion. They are probably better than the Steelers, but you watch the meltdown Sunday that is about to happen.

Steve: I thought Drew Allar may be able to get us over the hump to compete but cannot see them being competitive with USC, UCLA, Oregon and Washington joining the Big Ten in the next two years. How quickly does Penn State become the Pitt of the Big Ten, or way worse, once these teams join (understanding they pretty much are already because Franklin can’t beat Michigan or Ohio State)?

Zeise: Pitt won the ACC two years ago, so I am not sure how that little backhanded insult actually works in this context. The Big Ten is going to get much tougher for everyone in the next few years, but for Penn State, it gets easier. They are no longer stuck in the Big Ten East, which means they won’t get Michigan and Ohio State every year. I will be interested to see how some of these other teams do in the Big Ten because most of them are finesse teams. Penn State will be fine. I am not sure about Allar, but the program is in good shape, and James Franklin has recruited well.

Advertise with us

Tad: How many Power Five schools will go “no bowl, no NCAA tournament”? It’s tough to do — Pitt, Vanderbilt, Arizona State, Wake Forest (maybe). Were we all too quick to praise Heather Lyke for the state of Pitt athletics?

Zeise: The answer is yes, to the second question at least. I think Heather Lyke has done a good job for the most part, but the over-the-top praise for the job she has done — when you look at things like coaching hires and fires, the state of the two revenue-generating sports teams and the lack of fundraising for some of the major projects — is a bit much. It is nice all those Olympic sports teams are doing well, but every athletic director is judged by what their men’s basketball and football teams are doing because they drive revenue.

Curt: Why do you and many others have hatred for the SEC? With the playoffs completed, it seems the SEC representative showed itself to be worthy of selection to the four-team playoffs. Why the hatred for the SEC?

Zeise: It has nothing to do with the SEC and everything to do with the ridiculous way the college football committee bent over backward to accommodate a league that did not deserve it this year. The SEC was down this year, and Alabama did not deserve to be in the playoffs ahead of an undefeated Power Five champion. Period. The field should have been the three undefeated Power Five champions and Texas, who smoked Alabama at Alabama and then won the Big 12. This isn’t hard. The committee made a terrible decision and screwed a Florida State team that did everything it was supposed to do. And they did so because they bent down and kissed the brass ring of the SEC, which is nonsense.

Joey: I just saw where a bunch of current and former female student-athletes from Oregon have filed suit under Title IX for not receiving fair NIL payments, among other things. Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the NCAA have nothing to do with who gets paid in NIL money? Isn't it up to private donors on whether they want to pay a student-athlete for their name, image and likeness?

Advertise with us

Zeise: Yes, I think the pretzels the courts will have to tie their minds into to try to make this one fit are going to be fun. Get your popcorn. You are right — it is private entities that hand out the NIL deals. But the NCAA players are the ones who receive them, and I am sure the courts will try to find some way to regulate it. I don’t know if it will work, but I am sure this is going to be a very long and entertaining legal fight.

Xavier: What argument in sports do you think is the most manufactured? For instance, my pick would be the old, "What team would you not want to play?" any time a league's postseason starts.

Zeise: The whole “culture” thing is absurd to me. You know what I have found? When you win, the culture is always very good. When you lose, the culture is always really bad. The fact that some people actually believe that you can artificially manufacture culture or that some coaches manufacture culture is silly. When a team wins, the culture in the locker room is always much better than when they lose.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise