It took less than three months, but Pitt chancellor Joan Gabel finally kicked the hornet’s nest in order to wake up the “on-campus stadium” wackos of the Panthers fan base.

Actually, given that her first official day on the job was July 17th, she managed to pull it off in less than two months, which is impressive.

That’s because this “on-campus” stadium discussion and the small but vocal minority of people who still think it is necessary for Pitt football to thrive can’t let it go. That’s why it came up this week in an interview and why Gabel said just enough to fan the flames of speculation even more.

“It’s a big change to bring that kind of traffic to a new location, whether it’s on campus or somewhere else in the city,” Joan Gabel told the Tribune-Review. “But I am absolutely open to the exploration and to the evaluation.

Advertise with us

“I think we’re due for master planning. And so it’s probably time to certainly include that in the questions we would ask ourselves about the future of campus.”

I can save Gabel, the University of Pittsburgh and the athletic department millions of dollars in studies by giving them this evaluation: Building an on-campus stadium would be a colossal waste of money and won’t do a single thing to improve Pitt’s football program.

It won’t improve recruiting, it won’t improve attendance, and it won’t suddenly vault Pitt to the top of the world of college football. It won’t do anything except allow you to brag about having an on-campus stadium that cost an enormous amount of money and looks pretty.

Pitt’s football program is fine playing at Acrisure Stadium, and it makes far more sense than trying to build a stadium in Oakland.

There is access from all sides of the city to the North Shore, on good roads built for lots of cars. There is very limited access to Oakland from the west and south of the city, and to a lesser extent the north.

Advertise with us

If you have ever tried to get in and out of Oakland to see a sold-out event at Petersen Events Center — which holds 12,500 — you understand what a logistical nightmare it is and how much traffic backs up. Now multiply that amount of people by four, and imagine what that would be like.

So in short, once you get to the Oakland exit ,it could take you longer to get to where you are going to park as it did to get to the exit. I’ve sat in traffic on the ramp up to Oakland from the Parkway East for 20-25 minutes trying to get to events at Pitt in the past.

And that brings me to the next point: Where is everyone going to park?

There is adequate parking on the North Shore, but where exactly are you going to put parking for 45,000-50,000 people in Oakland?

It makes no practical sense to try and build a stadium in Oakland for so many reasons that the fact so many on the outside and within the university continue to talking about it is ridiculous.

Advertise with us

A number of athletic department officials and some key people from the university at large have had ongoing discussions about this for at least the last three or four years. There have even been a few models thrown about and some preliminary looks at the feasibility of it all.

Gabel was just answering a question, so I don’t blame her. But this is one of those things that needs to go away for a long, long time. It just doesn’t make sense, especially considering the reasons I am always told it has to happen.

Here are the reasons and why they are nonsense:

1.) It will help attendance!

Actually, it would probably hurt attendance because getting in and out of Oakland would be a logistical nightmare. The only people who would benefit from an on-campus stadium are students, but student tickets basically sell out every year. The university has done a great job of making it easy for students to get to the game, which is why the student section is always full even when the rest of the stadium is half-empty. And let’s get this straight — when Pitt had a stadium in Oakland and even when they had a team that was competing (and winning) national championships, they didn’t sell out and didn’t have a full student section. So the attendance thing is a myth — Pitt’s program has struggled to sell tickets because it was wallowing in the wilderness of mediocrity for 35 years or so.

Advertise with us

Here is the other thing: They are talking about “right sizing” the stadium and that Heinz Field is too big for Pitt’s crowd. However, there are a few games that Pitt has which will sell 65,000-70,000 seats, but you can’t do that if your stadium only holds 48,000-50,000 seats. If the empty seats on some game days offend people that much, put some tarps up on the upper deck and move on.

2.) It will help recruiting!

I have no idea how it would help recruiting. None. The current stadium is nice and it is an NFL stadium, and that in and of itself is a selling point. I can’t imagine there is any measurable number of players who would say, “If Pitt had a stadium in Oakland instead of the North Shore, I would have went there.” Recruits are choosing Pitt for the school, the conference, the coaching staff, the weight room and facilities, the NIL money, etc. The location of the stadium is not likely in the top 10 reasons a kid might or might not choose Pitt.

The facilities on the South Side are a different story, and if you want to tell me that Pitt should move those back to Oakland, I might agree. But those facilities don’t come with the traffic flow and parking issues, although I have no idea where a facility like that, complete with practice fields, would fit in Oakland, either. There are some discussions about Pitt and the Steelers outgrowing the South Side facility and one of them eventually having to move but that is a lot of talk now.

3) Nostalgia!

Advertise with us

Oh, please. Pitt Stadium was mostly a dump and the Panthers played a lot of really bad football there. As I always say, Ppease look at Pitt from about 1936 to about 2000 — all in an on-campus stadium — and tell me how much outside of the era from 1975-1983 is worthy of all of this nostalgia. And nostalgia doesn’t pay the bills, either.

4) Pitt could control its own schedule!

This is hilarious because the ACC has more control of Pitt’s schedule than Pitt. And the number of conflicts Pitt has with the Pirates is so minimal and has caused so few scheduling headaches it isn’t even worth talking about. This is silly.

Pitt, like many universities, has been concerned with funding and budgets in recent years and has had to have some tuition raises and whatnot, as well. But now you are going to convince me that spending $1 billion on a stadium that isn’t necessary and won’t improve the football program is a good idea?

Gabel’s answer to the question about a new stadium was mostly a nothing burger, but it was enough red meat to get the usual crowd clinging to this pipe dream salivating.

Advertise with us

But the idea of an on-campus stadium and the practicality of pulling it off are worlds apart, and the fact that otherwise intelligent people continue to entertain it is mind-numbing to say the least.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter.com