The Penguins re-signed Kris Letang for six years at a very team-friendly $6.1 million per year.

It may not seem very team friendly in Years 5 and 6, but the objective was to keep him on the team until retirement, and the Penguins accomplished that. Letang is the Penguins’ best defenseman, probably their second-best player and in some ways their most important player.

It is obviously still Sidney Crosby’s team. He is their captain and the MVP, but Letang’s role is critical to everything the Penguins want to do, especially on the power play. He is an ironman who plays big minutes nearly every game, and that’s mostly because there aren’t many people with his skill set.

It made perfect sense for the Penguins to want to sign him and want to keep him around for the next few years, especially at that price. And let’s face it, Letang is essentially going to get the money he was looking for, it will just take him two years longer and at that point he will be ready to retire. But I’m sure he was looking for something like $36 million over four years ($9 million per) and instead settled for $36.6 million over six ($6.1 million per).

Advertise with us

It was a win-win. The team got some salary cap help, and Letang basically signed a nice retirement package.

The Penguins now have Crosby and Letang to build around for at least the next three years (when Crosby’s deal expires) but likely more. They also kept veteran Bryan Rust around with a new contract, so they have three of their main core players signed, sealed and delivered for a long enough time to take a few more shots at the Stanley Cup. And like Letang’s deal, Rust’s was team friendly and he absolutely should have been a main priority in the offseason.

That brings us to the final major question with respect to the Penguins’ offseason, and that is what to do about Evgeni Malkin?

Malkin, along with Letang and Crosby, make up the core trio of players who have led the Penguins to three Stanley Cup championships. He is an all-time great, a first-ballot Hall of Famer and still a very productive player who at times can still look like one of the best players in the world.

All of that being said, the answer to the question is very simple, even though the Penguins and many around the team are making it very complex. The Penguins should give Malkin a gold watch as a thanks for his service, put together his career highlights in a some sort of tribute video, and move on from him.

Advertise with us

The fact that they haven’t or that they are even entertaining signing him for three or four years is ridiculous. Malkin still has the ability to be a great player when he is healthy — but that should absolutely be a consideration, considering he hasn’t been terribly reliable in recent years.

Malkin is closing in on age 36, he is coming off major knee surgery and he has appeared in just 129 of a possible 207 games over the last three seasons. He isn’t getting any younger and he is trending in the wrong direction in terms of reliability and avoiding injury.

The Penguins have reportedly offered him a three-year deal, he reportedly wants a four-year deal, and there is a bit of a game of chicken between the two parties going on. I just don’t get it, to be honest, especially given the fact that the Penguins have a lot of areas they need to upgrade and limited cap space.

I think it would be a bad deal to give Malkin a three-year deal, but I could be sold on it, I suppose. I do understand the idea of keeping the core together and trying to make another run or two. I don’t think there is any evidence this core has another run in them, though, as they have lost five playoff series in a row and been knocked out in the first round four consecutive times.

So three years would be a bad move, but it isn’t completely crazy and that’s not that long of a contract. But four would be lunacy. Malkin doesn’t have four more years at a high level left in his body. He isn’t Letang and Crosby, who are both workout fiends and both are still playing some of the best hockey of their careers.

Advertise with us

The Penguins have too many other needs to get sentimental with a big chunk of their remaining $15 million or so under the salary cap to sign an aging star with recent injury issues. If they sign Malkin even to a $5 million deal, they are limiting their options to really upgrade their roster.

Malkin has had a great run with the Penguins and he deserves to be honored as an all-timer. But his time with the Penguins should come to an end if they want to legitimately build a contender around Crosby and Letang because the salary cap space he will command could be better used elsewhere.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise