The Pirates will begin the season Thursday in St. Louis in Year 3 of the rebuilding plan under Ben Cherington and company. They aren’t going to contend, so there are many among the fan base who wonder out loud why anyone should care about them this season.
I suppose if the win-loss record is the only way to measure a team’s progress under a newer front office then we can tune out now and wait until next year ... or the year after.
I get that sentiment, but it is short-sighted. It takes some time and patience to build a baseball team from the ground up, even under perfect conditions. And given the economics of baseball and the Pirates’ reluctance to spend money, it takes even longer and can be near impossible to do.
Pirates fans, though, should embrace the process and judge the team on its progress. They appear to have done a good job of adding talented prospects to the farm system. That is definitely step one because eventually those prospects will become major league players or can be used as chips to acquire major league players.
That’s been the Pirates’ focus since Cherington took over as general manager, and I would expect that will always be a piece of the puzzle. If the team can keep a steady flow of prospects into the organization, then it can always have a pipeline of players ready to step up to the MLB team when the top players become too expensive.
I know it is a never-ending story with the Pirates, but the organization hopes it will end with the MLB team some day soon becoming a legitimate contender with the ability to achieve some sort of sustainability. It is a long-term, long-haul approach and one that many fans have become tired and suspicious of.
Read More
And this season is going to happen, so it can’t be completely dismissed as meaningless. True, there is no real difference between losing 100 games and losing, say, 92 or 93, but I do think that wins and losses should start to matter at least a little bit. And let’s face it, if the Pirates are going to improve on their 101-loss season of a year ago by 8-10 wins, it will mean that some of the good things that need to happen for this year to be a success actually did.
That starts with Mitch Keller and JT Brubaker taking the next natural steps as pitchers. The Pirates don’t have a plethora of good young pitchers like they do hitters, and that means these two have to get better. It is now or never for Keller, who apparently has found about 5 mph on his fastball and has shown some signs he may be ready to be a good pitcher for the Pirates over the next few seasons. But he has to go out and do it on a daily basis, and that is something he hasn’t been able to do.
Keller is not an ace, but if he settles in as a strong No. 3 or a solid No. 2, it gives the Pirates something to build the pitching staff around. Brubaker isn’t much more than a back-end-of-the-rotation pitcher, but again, if he proves he can be a consistent performer who gives the Pirates a chance to win, it gives some hope that the staff doesn’t need to be completely rebuilt.
Another great sign of progress is if at some point Roansy Contreras gets the call from Class AAA and stays with the Pirates the rest of the season after he does. He is the Pirates’ top pitching prospect, and while he probably needs some more time in Triple-A, if he progresses early in the season enough to prove he is major league ready, that would be a very good development, as well.
Ke’Bryan Hayes, whom the Pirates offered a long-term deal to over the weekend, is another player who needs to make significant progress as a hitter this year. If he truly is the centerpiece the Pirates are trying to build around, he has to be more than a defensive whiz who flashes some power and ability to hit from time to time. He needs to become a consistent producer and one of the anchors of the lineup.
Another great sign would be if Oneil Cruz is called up and makes it impossible for the Pirates to send him back. Cruz needs to show he can be a viable outfield option — as does Diego Castillo, who is an infielder but has been approached about moving.
These (and I suppose Cole Tucker also figuring it out at the plate) are just a few of the major developments the Pirates desperately need for this season to be a legitimate sign of progress and thus a success. I am not saying they will all happen, but most of them need to or this season will unquestionably be an utter disappointment, regardless of if they avoid 100 losses.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.