Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. You can also chat about all sports with Paul at noon Thursdays. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Joey: Why is Mike Tomlin so hesitant to hire assistant coaches from outside the Steelers organization?
Zeise: Great question. I think part of it is he wants to give his guys an opportunity to advance in their careers. He obviously has a certain comfort level with his own coaches. They know what he wants and what he expects. They understand what the Steelers organization wants and how it operates. There is also an element of finances as well as the Steelers don’t traditionally pay their assistant coaches as well as other organizations, so promoting from within enables him to hire coaches who won’t command big salaries. I think on the defensive side of the ball he clearly wants to keep control of play calling, and it is a difficult sell to an assistant who has other options and wants to call plays.
Steven: When Roethlisberger went down with his major elbow injury he was still one of the top QBs in the league. When he came back a year later he was ok but clearly diminished. I don’t believe his mobility was really that much different and his arm strength was debatable but his accuracy certainly was not there. Do you equate this very sudden decline more to the elbow injury or age? I’m sure the correct answer is both but what do you think had more of an impact?
Zeise: I think the combination of a major injury and it being late in his career is the right answer. I think if he had that same injury when he was 25, it wouldn’t have been so tough for him to come back from: At 37 or whatever he was at the time, the healing and recovery process takes longer. He was not the same player when he returned, which is why we got two years of the worst rendition of the dink and dunk offense.
Read More
Tyler: Can the Steelers utilize JuJu like the 49's use Deebo Samuel?? They are the same size (JuJu is a little taller). JuJu is physical and is not shy about contact. At a minimum, it would give other teams something else to game plan for. The question is based on the Steelers having a functional o line in 2022.
Zeise: I don’t know that he is that kind of talent. I think JuJu Smith-Schuster is a decent enough player, but there is nothing special about him. He isn’t fast, he doesn’t have quick change of direction and he isn’t great after the catch. He does block well and catches the ball well, so he has a place as a possession receiver. But he isn’t Deebo or anything close, to be honest.
Jay: Could Andy Reid’s success in Kansas City after being fired in Philadelphia be the reason Rooney wants to hang onto Mike Tomlin another year or two? To see what Tomlin can do if he gets a castoff-but-experienced-and-somewhat-mobile qb, followed by a low enough draft pick in a draft with more quarterback depth in the 2022 draft?
Zeise: The question was very long so I tried to shorten it and paraphrase it as much as possible without losing the meat of it. If I read it correctly, the answer is yes and no. I don’t believe Andy Reid’s situation specifically is why the Steelers hold on to Mike Tomlin. For one thing, they don’t like to fire coaches anyway. I think they have a philosophy with Tomlin that he is a good coach who has won before, so if you keep him through the rebuild he will take you to the top again. I am a fan of changing things from time to time, but I understand the need for stability.
Amy: How many more bad starts will Casey DeSmith get before the Penguins decide he needs to be replaced? Do you think the Penguins are leaving themselves vulnerable by not having a better backup goalie?
Zeise: Honestly, I think the Penguins are already there. Maybe he gets a couple more chances, but I think it is pretty clear they are nervous about him. They need to go take a look at what is out there and what they can find because they can’t go into the playoffs with DeSmith as their safety net.
Engstock: Here's a twofer. Is there any reason for Buffalo not to have squib kicked with 13 seconds left? And will Pittsburgh or Green Bay be first to break The Curse of the 2011 Super Bowl and get back to it?
Zeise: I have no idea what the Bills did in that final 13 seconds, but it was the most egregious choke job by a coaching staff I’ve ever seen. Not kicking the ball short was a start, defending the sidelines like the Chiefs had no timeouts and playing prevent when all they needed was a field goal are three things that are fireable offenses on their own. About the Packers and Steelers, I would say both are done for a while. Ben Roethlisberger and Aaron Rodgers are gone (Rodgers will be somewhere else next year), so the Packers will be rebuilding like the Steelers. It is gonna be a long time before either of them are back in the Super Bowl.
Tyler: Why is Jeff Capel still getting a pass in year 4? In comparison, Wake Forrest's head coach has them on a path to qualify for the NCAA Tournament in just his 2nd year on the job.
Zeise: Every situation is different and I would say Capel has not gotten a pass. There is a big difference between a pass and not having everyone call for him to get fired. He has to start winning and needs to start making progress in the standings, but I do think he has made a lot of progress. The team is getting better. They finally have an identity, and they finally look like an ACC team physically. I think staying the course for one more year and seeing if he can get it all the way on track is the best course. If you fire him now, you are starting over and nobody wants to do that.
Robbie: How is it that Louisville can fire their coach and Pitt wants to give their guy an extension? Chris Mack and Jeff Capel were hired at the same time, Mack’s record was much better than Capel’s and one is getting fired? Why are you such a homer for Capel? It is time for him to go and if you don’t think so maybe it is time for you to go as well
Zeise: Ha ha, yes I’m the ultimate homer for Capel. That is a good one. Now back to Earth — Louisville and Chris Mack had more issues than winning and losing. If you read about the situation it was a mess and was turning Into a disaster behind the scenes. It was a divorce that needed to happen and both sides will be better off. Mack will get another good job that maybe fits him better, and Louisville will hire another top coach who can maybe bring some peace and stability to the program. People at Pitt like Capel, believe in him and support him. That is a huge difference In the two situations.
Chad: What irks you the most when you are driving on the road with other motorists?
Zeise: Oh, without a doubt people who drive slow in the fast lane. Get out of the way. The left lane is for passing, so pass and move back over. A close second is idiots who don’t understand the concept of “use BOTH lanes until the merge point.” It isn’t hard: Get to the merge point and take your turn merging in. My favorite are people who try to make it so anyone at the merge point can’t merge in as if the ones who can read the sign and want to merge correctly are in the wrong. Get a life!
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.