My first reaction to the story about the Armstrong High School student section shouting vulgarities and sexually explicit chants at the female hockey goalie from Mars was to expel every kid that was involved from school and ban them from going to sporting events until they are 21 years old.
That’s the father in me coming out, which is why I had to take a few steps back and analyze the situation as it happened and consider what can and should be done. In case you missed the story, it is one that triggers a lot of emotions as well as a lot of questions. As Armstrong principal Kirk Lorigan told Post-Gazette sports reporter Mike White, the incident was both “embarrassing and unfortunate.”
What went on is vile and despicable — but I’ll be honest, it isn’t really the involved students who anger me most. They deserve to be disciplined, and it needs to be harsh and swift to send a message that such behavior is absolutely unacceptable.
The group that deserves the most scorn, though, is the adults who were in the arena during the Armstrong-Mars hockey game. That includes coaches, officials and every adult fan who heard the chants and did nothing to stop them.
We as adults have education and experience to guide and steer young people in the right direction. It is up to us to hug kids when they need a hug, protect kids when they need protected (like the Mars goalie, in this case) and give correction and discipline when it is merited (like with this student section).
The students who shouted these kinds of things during this game obviously are ignorant. They need to be educated and, in some cases, re-educated. That’s our job as adults.
Read More
They need to be disciplined but they also need to understand why their words are so hurtful. Their words go way beyond just “having some fun” and they need to understand why the attitudes they have toward women could escalate from abusive language to abusive actions if they go unchecked.
What were the adults in the room doing when this transpired? I have watched several videos from the game, and it is crystal clear what the students are chanting. How in the world could this go on, and not a single adult steps up to stop such appalling behavior? In this case, the adults in the room were enablers and deserve as much — actually more — criticism than the students.
Some people will try and turn this into some sort of referendum on the Armstrong community or its high school. It is not that. This is a referendum on the individuals who were in that arena and failed to take action. And, if your attitude was “it was just kids being kids,” then you are just as ignorant as the students who were chanting.
This also isn’t about the goalie “growing thicker skin,” as this language crossed many lines of decency and went into the world of harassment — and beyond. These chants were far more personal and harmful than any normal jeering that comes from a student section.
I understand that this was not a school activity and didn’t take place on school grounds, meaning there are some limitations in terms of what the Armstrong Area School District can actually do. Club hockey in Western Pennsylvania isn’t school-sponsored but rather governed by the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Hockey League (PIHL).
Lorigan, the Armstrong High School principal, and the PIHL both said there will no longer be students allowed at games, but that is not particularly meaningful nor does it correct behavior. Every one of the students who were chanting also should be required to complete 20-plus hours of community service with an organization that works with women who have been victims of abuse. Discipline, in this case, needs to include an educational component, or it won’t be particularly meaningful.
The school is investigating who was responsible for these actions. Any students who were involved should be immediately suspended from their school activities. And that includes any football players who were a part of it. There is no way they should be allowed to suit up this Friday for Armstrong’s first-round playoff game against Montour.
“But that punishes the other players on the team who worked so hard to get to the playoffs!”
Yep, so take it up with the players who made the decision to participate in this nonsense.
The PIHL and Armstrong Hockey Association are scheduled to meet Wednesday evening to discuss potential disciplinary action and changes at future games. The adults in this case failed these students once by not putting a stop to what was a horrifying scene. Let’s just hope they don’t fail them again by declining to enact adequate discipline.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @PaulZeise.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.