There is a cynical side to the Pirates fan base that believes the franchise’s biggest problem is that it is still owned by Bob Nutting. And as long as that doesn’t change, every other move that has been made is cosmetic.

I certainly understand that sentiment, as Nutting has often limited the payroll to a point where it is hard for the team to compete. He certainly hasn’t endeared himself to the fan base because it seems as if every decision he has made comes down to maintaining his profit margin.

I, too, have been guilty of criticizing Nutting for his lack of willingness to give the Pirates the best chance to compete.

That being said, Nutting has proven in the past month that he does care about winning and losing on some level. He has proven that he does indeed care about what the fan base thinks and he does want to build a franchise that is a model for small-market teams everywhere.

Advertise with us

Nutting did what many fans — and many of us media types — never thought he would do. He cleaned house in the front office by pushing Frank Coonelly and Neal Huntington out the door. He moved on from Clint Hurdle, whose time here probably did expire.

And in the process, he ate about $10 million in salaries owed for men who will not be working for the Pirates for the next two years.

You can sit here and say “that’s how real sports franchises operate,” but up until this past month, that’s not how the Pirates under Nutting have operated. He was fiercely loyal to Coonelly and Huntington and he was never going to spend that kind of money to make people go away.

That’s why he deserves the chance to get it right. I know I have an open mind now, especially after he made the decision to hire former Penguins executive Travis Williams as the team president. Williams is smart, has winning pedigree, understands what it takes to be a part of a winning culture and he loves the Pirates and has a passion for making them great.

Williams and Nutting met with the media Monday, and both men were impressive. Nutting was genuine, seemed to have all the right answers (except when it came to questions about payroll, when he danced around actually answering them) and made it pretty clear he shares the same frustrations of the fans.

Advertise with us

Nutting said it became “crystal clear” to him by about August that real sweeping changes were needed to be made. He cited a number of reasons for his decision to make changes, but the one that seemed to be the final straw was “watching so many of our players perform so well for other teams.”

He said that’s why the Pirates need to look at what they are doing in drafting and development and find ways to get back on the cutting edge in baseball. He talked about a fresh approach, new methods and perhaps even allocating money away from other areas and into payroll.

I know we have heard it all before, but it is worth giving Nutting the chance to prove he can get it right this time. Obviously, any moves without an increase of some substance to the payroll will likely have minimal impact, so that has to be a part of the equation.

But Williams — who had a great job and who has been a part of championship teams — said one of the biggest selling points for him was Nutting’s “commitment and his passion for bringing a winning team” to Pittsburgh. Williams said Nutting assured him that he is willing to offer support any way he can in order to make it happen.

That, if nothing else, should be reason for hope because I cannot for one second believe Williams would have taken the job without some assurances that Nutting will do better in terms of financially supporting the  team.

Advertise with us

I don’t believe that means Nutting will open up his wallet and spend $150 million on payroll, I just think it means he will be a little less quick to save every dollar possible.

A new era of Pirates baseball began Monday. And even though Nutting is still in place, it should have Pirates fans excited because it seems like he is committed to winning.

That might not be something he deserves a lot of credit for, since it is the way he is supposed to do things. But It seems like he is committed to doing things differently, and so he deserves the benefit of the doubt until he proves otherwise.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter @paulzeise.