Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:

Rob: If the Steelers finish 3-13 or 4-12, do you think GM Kevin Colbert will be fired for trading away a top 5 draft pick for a decent safety?

Paul: I don’t see that happening at all. He may choose to walk away on his own, but I don’t see any scenario where he gets fired. And I get it, Fitzpatrick was the 11th overall pick and the pick the Steelers traded to get him might be higher than that. I don’t think that matters — the Fitzpatrick deal was a great one for the Steelers because they picked up a budding superstar who had proven he can play in the NFL, and the draft is still a big crapshoot. Colbert may decide to retire, but he wants to finish on a positive note and isn’t likely to retire after a horrible season. So I really believe that, unless something dramatic changes between now and then, Colbert will be the Steelers’ general manager at least one more year after this one.

Bill: The Rooneys aren’t Dan Snyder (who just fired his coach), but what's the difference between 0-5 and 1-4 in a 16-game season, filling with a team not ready to compete?

Advertise with us

Paul: Jay Gruden accomplished almost nothing in six years in Washington. He won one division title, had a losing record, had only two winning seasons and never won 10 games in a season or a playoff game. He simply ran out of the benefit of the doubt, and frankly didn’t really earn it. Mike Tomlin has won a Super Bowl, been to another, won 100-plus games and a bunch of division titles. The two aren’t even comparable. Tomlin has never had a losing season, so even if the Steelers go 2-14 this year, he will — and should — be back to try to get it right next year.

Ron: Why have you flip-flopped on your stance re: Mike Tomlin? Whatever happened to "Nobody gets to keep their job forever"?

Paul: I have no idea what this means or what this is referring to, but you couldn’t be more wrong. My stance on Tomlin is simple: He has done far more good than bad and deserves the benefit of the doubt. He hasn’t had a losing season yet. Now, if he doesn’t get it right next season, then a change will be needed because that will be three non-playoff years in a row. He doesn’t have a lifetime pass, but he does have some benefit of the doubt he should be afforded based on what he has accomplished.

Joe: Do you find it worrisome that Steelers third-round draft pick, CB Justin Layne, has not even been activated for a game this season? A third-round pick should at least be seeing the field from time to time.

Paul: Not really. They picked him knowing he was a bit of a project and might take a little bit of time to develop. Steven Nelson has played really well, and Joe Haden has been their best corner since he was signed a few years ago, so there is no need to rush him along. Now, Nelson is hurt and if he can’t go this week, then maybe Layne will get a helmet. Either way, when you pick a player you know needs development, it means you need to be patient with him and coach him along.

Advertise with us

Albert: Tampa Bay playoff game fans were twirling what looked suspiciously like Terrible Towels, but in both directions. My question: is there a preferred direction to twirl the Terrible Towel?

Paul: I have no idea what you are talking about — however, if someone out there has an answer for this, email me at pzeise@post-gazette.com and I’ll publish the answer next week.

Frank: What do you make of all the players in the baseball playoffs who are playing starring roles that used to be Pirates?

Paul: Daniel Hudson wasn’t very good here. Charlie Morton was average. Gerrit Cole seemed to be underachieving his last two years here. Mark Melancon was running out of gas. Austin Meadows was looking like he might have been an overrated prospect. Francisco Cervelli was declared unusable because of concussions. David Freese wasn’t much of a factor here. J.A. Happ was great here, but they couldn’t afford him. And yet here we are watching them all do wonderful things in the playoffs. It all speaks to exactly what I said last week when they fired Clint Hurdle: This organization is terrible at drafting and worse at developing players. The front office needs to be cleaned out immediately because there are far too many players who never seem to fulfill their potential here. Hurdle was a scapegoat; the real issue is Neal Huntington, Kyle Stark, Larry Broadway and that whole cast of characters that make up the front office. It needs to be changed or we will continue to see a lot of good players never fulfill their potential here and go elsewhere to do great things.