The “Johnny Cueto game” will go down as one of the most memorable and important games in Pirates history. It wasn’t to determine a championship like the “Bill Mazeroski game” but in some ways it was every bit as significant. That game, the 2013 wild card game between the Pirates and Reds at PNC Park was more of an exorcism than a baseball game, as 20 years of losing officially came to an end.

It turned out to be the summit of the Pirates’ three-year playoff run because it was the only time they advanced in the playoffs, as the lost in the NLDS and then lost in the wild card game the next two years. I’ve been fortunate to have been at a lot of big-time sporting events, and none have come close to the atmosphere that was in PNC Park that night that Cueto dropped the ball.

That was Clint Hurdle’s third season as Pirates manager, and at that point and at any time over the next two seasons, he could have run for mayor of this town and won in a landslide. His popularity was at an all-time high, he was the voice and face of the Pirates, he had a blue collar approach and his folksy style really resonated with fans in this town. He dove into the city’s conscience, he became a big part of the community and involved himself in numerous charitable endeavors and was always accessible to the fans.

General manger Neal Huntington said Sunday that Hurdle “bleeds black and gold,” and I believe that. He loved this city, this franchise and its fans and he loved being the manager of the Pirates. And of course, he was the manager that broke the streak of losing seasons and made the Pirates relevant again.

Advertise with us

And that is precisely why, despite the way it ended, Hurdle should be revered by Pirates fans and is owed a debt of gratitude by the organization. Hurdle, who was fired Sunday by Neal Huntington, clearly ran out of gas. It was time, as it seemed like his message was stale and he was bordering on burnout.

The end, though, shouldn’t define Hurdle’s time here.

Neal Huntington discusses firing of Clint Hurdle

Hurdle should be honored by the Pirates. He should be embraced by fans. He should be remembered for his part in what he did to, as Huntington said Sunday “re-bond this city with its baseball team.” Hurdle tapped into the fan base and understood how much it was starving for a winner. He spoke the language of sports fans here, he embraced the traditions of the Pirates and was a vocal supporter of the Penguins when they made their Stanley Cup runs a few years ago.

The Pirates announced they are starting a Hall of Fame for former players and managers. This is a proud franchise with a lot of Hall of Famers, superstars and worthy members. I would also hope, as part of the Hall of Fame, they will embrace the city’s proud Negro League tradition and honor players from the Crawfords and Grays. The Pirates should honor former managers Fred Clarke, Bill Mckechnie, Danny Murtaugh and Chuck Tanner since they all won World Series.

There are many who believe that Jim Leyland, despite not winning a World Series, should at some point be put in the Pirates Hall of Fame for his work with the franchise from 1990-92. And so should Hurdle, who is responsible for all four of the team’s winning seasons over the past 27 seasons. Hurdle’s teams played hard, they battled and until this season they never embarrassed the brand. And despite the fact that he had one of the cheapest owners in all of sports pulling the strings and took over an awful team, he managed to have a winning record (735-720)  in his time here. That’s actually quite an accomplishment.

Advertise with us

I have no doubt that the Pirates needed to move on from Hurdle, but only because it was clear that it was time. A new voice was needed as was a new direction, so I had no issues with the fact that he was fired (other than, as I wrote, the fact that he was a scapegoat and Huntington should have been shown the door, too).

He should be honored by the Pirates next season in some capacity, he should be honored again the 10th anniversary of the Cueto game in 2023, and he should be put in the Pirates Hall of Fame. The end was ugly, but fans will hopefully remember the good times that Hurdle brought and treat him as if he is one of the franchise’s all-timers.