Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. You can hear Paul’s show on 93.7 The Fan from 6-10 p.m. most evenings or after the Pirates play. Let’s get started:
Mark: What is the Steelers biggest problem? For me it is simple: Mike Tomlin. Stop making so many excuses for him; he isn’t a good coach.
Paul: I wrote about the offensive line earlier this week and that’s where I will begin. You have a first-time starter at quarterback and a lack of big playmakers on offense. The offensive line is supposed to be a strength of the team but didn’t do much to help Mason Rudolph. The Steelers couldn’t run the ball, either, and while some of it falls on James Conner, most of it falls on the line. The line has three Pro Bowl players and it has to play better than what we have seen so far. Mason Rudolph has proven that when he gets the time to throw, he is pretty good at making his reads and going through his progressions. The line has to get better.
Chad: What happened with Carli Lloyd supposedly getting tryout offers from two NFL teams to be a placekicker? Do you think that whole story was fabricated?
Paul: I didn’t think that it was real and frankly I hope it wasn’t. This is a dumb subject. Let her prove in semi-pro games that she can kick field goals before she gets a tryout. There are literally thousands of more qualified kickers who will never get a shot. I do believe a woman could kick in the NFL some day, but Lloyd has no football experience at all and is in her late 30s, and her 55-yard field goal came with multiple steps she wouldn’t have in a game.
Ron: Why do some think Mike Tomlin should be given a free pass for this season because he does not have Ben? What is he going to do if Ben never returns, and/or eventually retires?
Read More
Paul: He went into this season planning on having a Hall of Fame quarterback. When Roethlisberger retires or whatever, the Steelers will have time to put together a plan because he is likely to announce it in the offseason. I don’t think he gets a pass, per se, but I do think that if he doesn’t have Roethlisberger, he has to be judged differently — especially without Antonio Brown and Le’Veon Bell.
Jason: Has Antonio Brown played his last NFL game?
Paul: No. I even think he may get another shot this season. Players with talent have multiple lives. That’s a universal truth. As long as Brown is not convicted of a crime and is free, he is a threat to be signed by somebody. I defer to former NBA scouting director Marty Blake on these kinds of things. He was once asked about a 7-foot kid with character issues and whether or not he will still get drafted. Blake (paraphrase) responded: “If Charles Manson was 7-foot tall, someone would draft him and say ‘So he had a bad year or two.’ ”
Robert: What is truly stupid is someone who calls others stupid for subscribing to fact. Just exactly how much did Tomlin have to coach up the team he inherited? How has Tomlin coached since he’s been drafting his players? He has been loaded with offensive talent and still can’t beat teams he’s supposed to beat. How has he been at developing players? How’s his clock management? How about red-flag reviews?
Paul:The good news is you actually read my stories! So thanks for that. I stand by what I wrote the other day: If you are still spouting off about Tomlin winning with Cowher’s players, I can’t help you. Tomlin isn’t perfect, he has some flaws and needs to improve in some areas, but he is much better than a lot of coaches out there. And he usually does a nice job of keeping the team afloat during tough times.
Nathaniel: Do you think Landry Jones needs to fire his agent? A whole hell of a lot of QB depth evaporated in this league after last Sunday. Can’t help but wonder if he has some regrets signing with the XFL.
Paul: No. Landry Jones should take all that XFL money and run. He isn’t likely to get a good situation in the NFL again. He is a below average backup, so it isn’t shocking he has gotten many chances since he has been cut. He is functional enough that I think someone might give him some run, but I wouldn’t count on it.

Michael: How much of the criticism of Mike Tomlin is based in racism in your mind?
Paul: I don’t know how to quantify it. There definitely is an element of it, and it’s one of those things that I know when I hear it. Tomlin has done an excellent job and has a team that wants to play hard for him. Not all criticism of him — or even the majority — is due to racism. People are hard on coaches in this town.
Greg: I keep hearing you write and say on your show that Pitt should make its nonconference schedule weaker and schedule teams that are going to be virtually guaranteed wins. After watching Pitt beat Central Florida and all that has followed, do you still feel this way? I want to see Pitt player better teams, not get wins over bad or weaker teams.
Paul: They are still 2-2 and getting to double-digit wins is going to be very hard. Pitt should only schedule nonconference games with two things in mind: wins and big crowds. That’s it. If Pitt doesn’t play West Virginia, Michigan, Ohio State, Notre Dame or Penn State — i.e the five teams that ensure Heinz Field will be sold out — the Panthers should play four virtual locks for wins. Kansas State built a program like this. Syracuse became the toast of the football world last year doing this. Get four wins in the nonconference, and if you go 5-3 in conference play, you have a chance to get to 10 wins with a bowl game. There is no value in playing a team like Oklahoma State, which blew their doors off and brought no fans.
George: Do you think Joe Maddon, who is going to get fired by the Cubs, would be a good fit as the Pirates manager?
Paul: I would say only if Neal Huntington is fired, too. Maddon has issues with Theo Epstein and has talked openly about his disdain for the young whiz kid general managers who aren’t baseball guys. That would be a disastrous relationship between Maddon and Huntington from the start. If Huntington is gone and the right kind of general manager is hired, I would say sure, why not. Maddon proved he can do a great job with a smaller payroll in Tampa, and he has won a World Series. He brings instant credibility.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.