Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Today’s edition of the mailbag could be called “A whole lot of anger from Pirates fans.”

Let’s get started.

Mark: What do you think about the Pirates moving Jose Osuna to first base and Josh Bell to the outfield? I think it would make the Pirates a better team offensively and defensively.

Advertise with us

Paul: I have heard this suggestion on more than one occasion, and I can’t quite figure out why or what people are thinking. Bell isn’t a good first baseman, and he doesn’t really move particularly well. And he can’t throw from first base to home plate. What in the world makes anyone think he would be good in the outfield? It would be a disaster. If you must get Osuna into the lineup, he is a much better option in the outfield than Bell. I would play Osuna at third base for a volume of games and see how he handles that. I don’t think Bell is a good fielder, so first base may be the best place to try and hide him. Also, the Pirates outfield next year is going to be Gregory Polanco, Starling Marte and Bryan Reynolds. Who are you taking out of that outfield in order to make room for Bell or Osuna? It makes no sense.

Hal: What should be the Pirates starting lineup next season and rotation? And when you write it down and look at it - is it really good enough to compete?

Paul: If I were king of the world, it would be: Catcher X (a free agent catcher because the position needs an upgrade significantly), Bell 1B, Newman 2B, Tucker SS, Hayes 3B, Polanco RF, Marte CF, Reynolds LF. Bench/utility players: Osuna, Moran, Frazier, Diaz. The rotation: Trevor Williams, Chris Archer, Pitcher X (free agent), Pitcher X (free agent), Mitch Keller — Brault and Musgrove to the bullpen. That would be my vision for the Pirates putting their best foot forward in 2020 and beyond, but unfortunately I don’t get a vote.

Joe: If Bob Nutting holds nobody accountable for the latest Pirates collapse, do you think next season will see record low attendance?

Paul: No, I don’t. The ballpark is beautiful and there are enough bobbleheads, Skyblasts, T-shirts nights, puppy dog days, $1 hot dog days, fireworks nights, military nights and everything else to bring people to the stadium no matter what the team does. Attendance is actually up this year, which is amazing. I tip my cap to Frank Coonelly, as he and his team of marketing and promotions people are amazing in the way they can keep getting people to come to the park. He has done a great job of making a Pirates game an event that goes beyond the actual game.

Advertise with us

Charles: How is it possible that Neal Huntington, Clint Hurdle and Ray Searage will all likely keep their jobs after this season? This has been maybe the most disappointing season I can remember and that is saying something given the history of the franchise.

Paul: I am not lying in that I got this question asked in some version no less than 14 times this week. All I can say is, that is the way Bob Nutting does business. He owes Neal Huntington and Clint Hurdle two more years on a contract and isn’t likely to buy them out. I would be careful assuming Searage is back. I know he is well-regarded within the organization, but somebody has to take the fall. It isn’t going to be Huntington or Hurdle because, again, Nutting owes them both a lot of money. It won’t shock me if it is Searage and a couple of other coaches and maybe even a few members of the scouting department. There is no way that nobody is going to take a fall for this season. Somebody always takes the fall, but it won’t be Huntington or Hurdle.

Greg: Why do Pirate fans collectively accept failure year after year? This past weekend's series against the Mets drew no less than 23,000 for each game. Do you honestly think Nutting will change the way he does things if he keeps getting crowds like that?

Paul: Well, it was a beautiful weekend, weather-wise. The Pirates had two big promotions. And they only drew 23,000 a game. That is all you need to know. A few years ago, this would have been a weekend where 110,000 fans went through the turnstiles. Again, I tip my cap to Coonelly for being able to keep fans coming back, but even he knows that ship has sprung a leak. As former Pittsburgh Condors general manager Marty Blake once said, “You can sell tickets to a lot of things but you cannot promote a funeral.” It is clear fans aren’t buying what the Pirates are selling like they used to, and it will only get worse. That being said, it is a great place to go watch a baseball game still and that brings people back. People aren’t accepting losing, I don’t believe that for a second.

Alan: What, if any, incentive can we offer Bob Nutting to sell the team?

Advertise with us

Paul: Nothing. It is a golden ticket for him and his family and he has already said he wants to pass it down to his kids. If I told you that you can own a business that gives you $30 to $40 million in profit every year no matter what you do to it, would you sell it? There is no reason for Nutting to sell, which means he is here for a long, long time.

Bob: How can Steelers ownership travel to Florida to embrace and meet with a player like “Big Chest”, but cannot find the time to mend fences with Troy who lives in, and gives back to, the City of Pittsburgh?

Paul: It takes two to tango and my understanding is that the hard feelings are from Polamalu, not the Steelers. I am sure the Steelers would happily sit with Polamalu and try to hash this little rift out because he is an all-time great. But if Polamalu doesn’t want to talk to them or isn’t ready to forgive and forget, it isn’t on the Steelers. They can’t make him talk to them.

Jacob: The Steelers are a 7-9 team. Mark it down. I laugh when I see all these projections about them going to the playoffs. They got rid of their two best players and their defense still stinks. What makes you think that the defense is any better? One rookie? C’mon, man, you are better than that! Don’t believe the hype, mark it down, 7-9.

Paul: I was all for you until I realized that you are a Browns fan based on our interactions in the past. Tell you what, you worry about your beer-chugging, loud-mouth quarterback, clueless coach and diva receiver and let Steelers fans worry about the Steelers. I will say this — Mark Barron, Devin Bush and Steven Nelson will all be upgrades for the defense at places the defense needed upgraded. And even if the defense stinks, it will still be good enough to beat the Browns because, well, the Steelers always beat the Browns.