The third class of the Steelers’ Hall of Honor appears to be one person short. It technically is, given the committee only selected four people instead of five, but that’s not what has many shaking their heads.
“Where’s Troy and how could he not be in yet?” That is the burning question that many have asked. Troy, of course, is former Steelers safety Troy Polamalu, one of the greatest players in franchise history. Polamalu was a great player and one of the best NFL players I’ve seen. He was uniquely talented, incredibly clutch and could make plays that nobody else could make.
He is eligible for selection because he meets the basic requirements: He has been retired for more than three seasons, he played for the Steelers for at least three seasons, and he has noteworthy career highlights, records and achievements. And since he is eligible, he should be in and it should have been a no-brainer, right?
Well, no. In Polamalu’s case, it goes beyond his statistics and how great of a player he was. Those things are not in dispute and not even arguable. But he hasn’t been a part of the Steelers family since he retired, and that should be troublesome. Polamalu wanted to play one more year, but the Steelers believed he was done and forced his hand to retire before he wanted to.
This hasn’t sat well with Polamalu, who has not been back for any of the Steelers’ celebrations. He wasn’t at either of the celebrations of the two Super Bowl teams he played on. He has been fairly invisible since he retired in 2014 and has kept most of his thoughts about the situation close to the vest.
This is why the Steelers couldn’t put him in this class. It is why they can’t put him in the next couple classes, either. They can’t put a player in the Hall of Honor who doesn’t want anything to do with the organization. That just wouldn’t feel right and it wouldn’t look right when he no-showed the banquet.
Read More
Some people mock the idea that the Steelers didn’t pick Polamalu because they were afraid he wouldn’t show up for the ceremony. There is this idea that these things should be settled on merit alone, and in general I agree with that. I think Halls of Fame should be filled with the most qualified candidates and their on-field accomplishments and numbers are the only things that should matter.
I don’t view this Hall of Honor the same way as I would a Hall of Fame, though. Polamalu will be eligible for the Pro Football Hall of Fame next year and he should absolutely get in on his first try. He transformed the safety position and was a dominant, game-changing player.
The Hall of Honor, though, honors people who were not only great but also embrace their time with the Steelers franchise. This is an honor that only a relative few players in franchise history will receive, and if it doesn’t mean enough to a player to show up to be honored, then they should be left out.
It is my hope that the Steelers and Polamalu find a way to bury the hatchet. It needs to be done. He is simply too important of a player in franchise history to be on the outside of these things looking in. He is one of the faces of the Steelers’ second Super Bowl era, and a number of his big plays are among the most memorable in franchise history.
The Steelers didn’t do anything wrong, though; it was time for them to move on from Polamalu. Every player gets to a point in his career when it is time to hang it up, and some handle that better than others. Players are gently pushed into retirement every year, so this grudge Polamalu seems to have needs to be let go.
I believe Polamalu will eventually be able to forgive and move forward, and that will, I’m sure, be a great day for the Rooneys and everyone in the organization. He needs to come home and he needs to embrace his legacy and the career he had while wearing the uniform.
The day that happens is the day he should be put into the Hall of Honor, but until then, he needs to continue to be on the outside looking in. It is his choice, and maybe he will never come around, but the Steelers can’t honor a man who doesn’t seem to want to be honored.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.