The Pirates went from one of the feel-good stories of the season to a complete disaster in less than three weeks. That isn’t easy to pull off, but that’s what happens when a team goes 2-10 during a critical stretch of the season. The Pirates are still not getting enough quality pitching and their bats have gone silent.

Ordinarily when a team starts to lose, there is an overreaction by fans and media alike that heads need to roll and changes need to be made. It is generally not the right approach because these things are often cyclical, and if an organization is doing the right things and has quality people making decisions, it will usually find its way out of the funk.

That is why the small sample size model is a dumb one. It is good for hot takes and over-the-top reactionary opinions, but not much more.

This, however, is no longer a small sample size for this front office and the decision makers of the Pirates. They are 46-55 this year and that’s not good by any measure. There are some who will give the Pirates a pass because of some injuries, but they are just deluding themselves into believing in something that isn’t real.

Advertise with us

This team was built to be an 81-win team. The pitching staff that was compiled was just not good enough to give the Pirates a real chance to make a run at the playoffs. The lineup has actually been better than it appeared at the start of the season, but it has cooled off of late and seems to be regressing to what it was projected to be.

This isn’t even about one season, though, as every team can have a bad season from time to time. The Pirates could argue they are young and a year or two away and, hey, finishing with 81 wins means they are a little ahead of schedule

The big picture, though, is that the Pirates have played 585 baseball games since the end of the 2015 season. That was the year they won 98 games and lost in the wild-card game to the Cubs. That was also the last time they not only made but even came close to making the playoffs. They have a record of 281-304 since that time, which is about a .480 winning percentage.

That translates to somewhere between 77 and 78 wins in a typical season. If this were Year 2 or 3 of the Neal Huntington regime, it would be admirable considering the dumpster fire he inherited. It isn’t. This is Year 12 and Huntington and his front office have produced a lot of mediocrity and worse.

And right now, the organization isn’t even mediocre; it is actually slightly below average. This is an organization that needs a cleansing, a new philosophy, a new direction and some fresh ideas. The model they have utilized is broken and it is looking more like the three-year run of wild-card games was the exception, not the rule.

Advertise with us

The team competes at times, but there simply aren’t enough good players in the organization to compete at a high level. And I don’t want to hear that garbage about the economic model and the poor little small market team. The Pirates proved from 2013-15 that they can compete for playoff spots, so it isn’t impossible.

The pitching philosophy seems to do two things: get a lot of pitchers injured and hold a lot of pitchers back from their full potential. I know that is an oversimplification and maybe a bit unfair, but there is a lot of evidence suggesting it isn’t far off the mark. The organization doesn’t develop enough hitters. The drafts have been mostly “blah,” and it seems like there is nothing in the future that suggests it will change.

Huntington has done a lot of great things as general manager for the Pirates, but it feels like his time here has run its course. The organization has become stale. The way they do things doesn’t seem to be working. The Pirates waste too many draft picks, they make too many free agent signings that don’t pan out, and the two big trades he pulled off at last year’s trade deadline appear to be busts. I don’t know if it is time to move on from Huntington, but if it isn’t, it is certainly time for him to clean house and bring in a fresh group of people to get the Pirates back competing for playoff berths.

The Pirates have some good young players in place, but not nearly enough to feel good about what’s next for them. They need a lot of help and they need help from both within the organization and from the outside. I don’t think this current front office and coaching staff is capable of providing that help.

It is time for owner Bob Nutting to make some tough decisions and some major, sweeping changes — unless he is content with a product that has become slightly less than average.