The Steelers are bringing minicamp to a close Thursday and by all accounts it has been a success. It seems like the Steelers were focused on football and there were very few, if any, distractions or off-field incidents.
The players have talked openly and glowingly about the new, better atmosphere and attitude in the locker room. Ben Roethlisberger is a new man ready to be the leader that he has apparently not been, and he is seemingly excited about all of his new weapons. Teryl Austin has been added to the defensive staff and will apparently help Mike Tomlin on game day with replay challenges.
This week there were also several players who talked about returning to the Super Bowl and the holes in the roster that needed to be filled seem to be. By all accounts this has been a marvelous offseason for the Steelers as they shed two of their biggest locker room distractions, added an excellent defensive coach in Austin, and clearly shored up their defense through free agency and the draft.
All of that points to a team that is poised to have a great season, but it is only June and there is a long way to go before they play an actual game. There are a number of things that could happen to dampen the outlook for the season, but as of now, it seems like the Steelers are on the path back to Super Bowl contention.
The key to it all, though, is Keith Butler, who has to have his best year as a defensive coordinator if the Steelers are going to have any prayer of achieving any of their goals. Butler is entering his fifth season as the Steelers defensive coordinator and should absolutely be on the hot seat. The Steelers defense has blown too many leads, given up too many big plays and been responsible for losing too many games under his watch for his job not to be under scrutiny.
The Steelers have missed on a few key draft picks and an injury to Ryan Shazier has certainly not helped Butler have success. Those reasons only go so far before they begin to sound like excuses. And heading into this season he has been handed the necessary tools, so there should be no more excuses about personnel shortcomings and holes in the roster. The linebacker corps has been rebuilt, the secondary has been fortified, and the defensive line should be a team strength again.
Read More
The Steelers invested $37 million in free agent linebacker Mark Barron and cornerback Steven Nelson. They picked up the fifth-year option on linebacker Bud Dupree. Then they made a trade to move up 10 spots in the draft so they could draft linebacker Devin Bush, one of the top two rated players at his position in the draft. They also used one of their third-round draft choices to grab a big physical — albeit raw — cornerback in Justin Layne.
Butler knows that Bush is a key to the Steelers’ defensive improvement and is thankful Kevin Colbert made the bold move to draft him.
“I’m glad Kevin did what he did, to be honest with you,” Butler said Wednesday. “We knew what we wanted in the draft. The guys we wanted were the Devins — both Devins. When [Devin White] went early, Kevin did a great thing moving up.”
Bush isn’t the only player Colbert has handed to Butler to help upgrade the defense, and that’s why the pressure is squarely on Butler’s shoulders to put together a consistently effective unit. It is up to Butler now to prove he deserves a sixth year as defensive coordinator.
There has been some question as to how much Butler is in charge of the defense and how much Mike Tomlin meddles in it. That doesn’t matter because, regardless if Tomlin meddles or not, the defense is a direct reflection on the job Butler is doing.
If Tomlin has indeed taken over the defense and is writing the game plan and calling the plays, then Butler is the defensive coordinator in name only and the Steelers should move on from him. Conversely, if Butler has been completely in charge of the defense, then he is responsible for all of its shortcomings.
There are no more excuses for why the Steelers’ defense isn’t getting the job done, especially at critical times in critical games.
Butler needs to be better and he needs to finally and fully fix the defense. If he doesn’t, the Steelers will once again have a disappointing season — and if that happens, Colbert and Tomlin’s next major move will have to be to replace Butler with a new defensive coordinator.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.