Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
George: It is so painful to watch Chris Archer pitch. He is not the starter we need; his better days are behind him. What on earth are we doing with him? Maybe a three- to four-inning middle reliever, at best? What do you think?
Paul: If the Pirates send Chris Archer to the bullpen, the trade to get him will officially become one of the biggest busts in Pirates history. It is already in that neighborhood, and his five-homer performance Tuesday night didn’t help matters. He needs to become a lot better, and he should be, but he just can’t pull it all together. He is almost afraid to throw his fastball these days. He is almost afraid to throw any pitch except his slider in the strike zone. But he can’t go to the bullpen; they just don’t have enough starters arms to get through the season. The Pirates are stuck with him, and they just need to hope he can turn it around. The one thing they need to be able to do, though, is walk away from him in the offseason if this doesn’t get better. I know they gave up a lot to get him, but he just isn’t a good pitcher right now and isn’t helping them win games.
Nate: Why does Pirates management continue to do nothing to acquire pitching instead of calling up these guys from AAA who can't get anyone out?
Paul: Wait, what? You aren’t excited about the parade of Geoff Hartlieb, Dovydas Neverauskas, Clay Holmes, Rookie Davis, Montana DuRapau etc.? It is incredible how many pitchers the organization has who are either not good enough or not ready. This has been an embarrassment. I’ll listen to the idea that the starting rotation was devastated with two major injuries and deserves a little bit of a pass. But Keone Kela is the only reliever of consequence who has been hurt, and he was terrible when he was pitching. There is no depth with this organization, no pitching depth at all and it has shown in a big way. And the Pirates are not going to make a move to go get anyone and their rationalization will be that this is a lost season, so there is no need to give up any assets to try and win now.
Robert: Why does MLB not hold their umpires accountable for bad calls? No wonder they get worse and worse every year.
Read More
Paul: I think they do in some ways, but they don’t really make it public. Theoretically, the best umpires get to do the All Star Game and playoff games, so that is one way they are at least graded. There needs to be a lot more accountability, though, as too many games turn into an ump show. I am not a fan of the automated machines calling balls and strikes, but the strike zone of some of these umpires is really hard to defend. There seems to be no consistency at all. Joe Musgrove and Josh Donaldson should not have been thrown out of the game Monday, and the fact that they were is an embarrassment to Major League Baseball.
Chip: Why won’t the Penguins make changes this offseason? Jim Rutherford seems to think standing pat with this roster will be good enough for next season. They got swept by the Islanders. What makes him think they will be any better next year? I was very disappointed to read that he is no longer looking to trade Phil Kessel.
Paul: I don’t think he is standing pat or willing to go into next season with the roster intact. I think reality has set in — the Penguins have some older players on bad contracts and younger players who aren’t worth a whole lot on the open market. He had a deal in place to trade Kessel to Minnesota and it was nixed by Kessel, who has a no-trade clause in his contract. I guarantee you if someone calls and makes a reasonable offer and Kessel agrees to go to whatever team it is, he will be gone. Jack Johnson should be traded, but who in their right mind is taking that contract? Olli Maatta is a young defenseman who is slower than a lot of old defensemen. It is hard to imagine a return that makes sense for Evgeni Malkin. Kris Letang has a history of injury and illness and has a big contract. That really is the issue with the Penguins right now — who do they move and what can they get in return? Rutherford brought two Stanley Cups, so he probably has a lifetime contract. He has not had a good couple of years, and that much is reflected in a roster with a bunch of parts that likely cannot be moved unless the Penguins are willing to give them away for nothing and/or eat a bunch of their salaries.
Grayston: Are you going to be interested in the “Hard Knocks” shows this year now that we know it will be Antonio Brown and the Raiders on it? I think it has potential to be very entertaining.
Paul: I love “Hard Knocks.” It is one of my favorite things on television. I will be intrigued to see how that Raiders circus is portrayed. As for Antonio Brown, he bores me to tears. There is nothing interesting about him at all anymore. He is a circus act that is no longer entertaining or interesting.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.