The Pirates’ biggest problem right now isn’t a lack of high-end talent. It isn’t the lack of pitching depth. It isn’t the injuries they have had to overcome, either.
Those things are a symptom of a bigger problem that really hasn’t surfaced in Neal Huntington’s time as general manager until the last year. The Pirates are rudderless right now. They have no direction, seemingly no plan and no identity.
The moves they make now seem to be like putting on a blindfold and throwing a dart at the board. There is almost desperation now in their moves, and that’s especially true with the revolving door of relievers.
This season would be an easier sell to their fans if they appeared to have an idea of what they want to do and who they want to be. Instead, they are a team without an identity.
Are they young? Are they trying to rebuild? Are they trying to get to the playoffs this year? Are they going to sell and save money at the trade deadline and punt on this season?
These are all questions I used to know the answers to in Huntington’s time as the general manager. Now, I have no idea what they are doing and that likely means I am only slightly less informed than they seem to be. This team doesn’t seem to know what they are and what they want to be right now.
Read More
It is almost like the Pirates’ front office put together a team and then hoped everything would go right. The owner gave the team no margin for error. The front office tried to piece together a team they claimed was a contender using too many misfit parts.
The bullpen issues are a great example. The Pirates have a lot of players who are either not good enough or flawed — or, in the case of Francisco Liriano, way past his prime. Liriano has been amazingly good so far, but it shouldn’t surprise anyone if there is a regression. Sunday he was rocked by the Brewers and that is more likely to happen to him from time to time because he is at the stage of his career where he shouldn’t be counted on as a main reliever.
The Pirates also entered the season with a strange mix of players at shortstop and third base. They hoped Erik Gonzalez would somehow prove to be good enough and hoped Jung-Ho Kang would wipe off the cobwebs to have a monster season. In the military, they say, “Hope is not a method,” and yet, that seems to be the Pirates’ method these days.
All of the Pirates’ shortcomings in terms of talent, however, could be overcome if there were a plan in place. The Pirates could add a few pitchers if they needed to, and they do have Keone Kela and Trevor Williams coming back from injury soon.
They might not have high-priced players, but the way Josh Bell is swinging the bat would clearly qualify him as a high-end talent. They also have Bryan Reynolds, who appears to be a potential star, and as frustrating as Starling Marte can be at times, he is still one of the best center fielders in the majors.
There is now a five-man outfield, and the odd man out will likely be Melky Cabrera, who has been one of the best hitters on the team. He should be one of the guys who plays the majority of the days. That would suggest the team is actually trying to win. Instead, there is some sort of strange platoon with Corey Dickerson and Gregory Polanco in right, and Cabrera will be a pinch hitter.
A team that is trying to win would have Mitch Keller on the club and would not have opened a series in Milwaukee with Rookie Davis on the mound like they did Friday. Keller may not be completely ready, but desperate times call for desperate measures and he needs to be brought up and given a few starts.
All of this smells like a front office that is out of answers. They are lost and they aren’t sure how to find their way again. That’s not a good place to be and this is new territory for the Huntington-led Pirates. They need to figure out a plan for the near and long-term future and one that makes sense. They need to figure it out soon, or this season will become a complete loss — and worse, the next couple of seasons will be wasted, as well.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.