Heather Lyke joined The Fan Morning Show on Wednesday to talk about the state of Pitt sports as she enters her third year as athletic director. She spoke of coaching hires, new facilities on the horizon and more.
Lyke is an optimist and passionate, and there is no question that she has Pitt headed in the right direction. She has helped fully transition the athletic department to the ACC. She has made excellent hires, and she has set the bar high for everyone under her watch and hasn’t been afraid to challenge some of the old guard in their thinking.
But none of that will matter if the men’s basketball and football programs don’t improve and become nationally competitive.
That’s not to disrespect or discount the work of all the other coaches and athletes at Pitt. But Pitt could win a dozen national titles in those sports and it won’t change the outside perception of Pitt unless the men’s basketball and football programs improve and have success.
Is that unfair? Nope, it isn’t. It is the way of the world in college athletics, and it isn’t unique to Pitt. If Penn State’s football team was going 4-8 every year, I’m quite sure very few of Penn State’s donors would be in the mood to celebrate the volleyball team’s success. The same can be said at West Virginia, although unlike Penn State and a lot like Pitt, it isn’t just football; men’s basketball also helps drive the bus.
The trick for Pitt is to define what success is for both programs, and it’s pretty clear that it’s different in the two sports.
Read More
The football program came close last season to what is a realistic goal and what would constitute real success. They went 6-2 in the ACC Coastal, won the division and played in the ACC championship for the first time. It is realistic to think the Panthers should be in the hunt every year for a Coastal Division title, and by extension that means an ACC championship isn’t an unrealistic goal, either.
A division title is a big deal, but last season also illustrated how far Pitt has to go as a program. Pitt was 1-5 in the rest of their games. That included blowout losses to Penn State, UCF and Clemson and a horrible loss to a depleted Stanford team in the Sun Bowl. Pitt also lost to a brutally bad North Carolina team and a Miami squad devoid of an offense.
The basketball program’s success is a little easier to measure because we have seen recently what it looks like at its best. Pitt has been a No. 1 seed in the NCAA tournament, been ranked in the top 10, won conference regular season and tournament titles and played in huge games in front of sold out arenas and national TV audiences.
Jeff Capel has a long way to go to build it back to that, and that’s a really high standard to achieve. He doesn’t have to do all those things quickly, but he does need to continue to build the program back to the point where it is a ranked, perennial NCAA tournament contender that plays in big, meaningful games.
Capel is recruiting well and is an excellent coach, so he should be able to get the program up and running again. Narduzzi has made some really good coaching hires and has a talented team that has a lot of players who have played a lot of football. The future looks bright for both programs, but until the lights actually come on and both arrive, the perception of Pitt’s athletic department won’t change for the better.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.