Mitch Keller made his MLB debut in the nightcap of a doubleheader against the Reds on Monday, and predictably it didn’t go very well as the Pirates lost 8-1. Keller gave up six runs before the end of the first inning, and that was mostly due to the grand slam he served to Jose Iglesias. It shouldn’t be a surprise, as Neal Huntington told reporters just last week he wasn’t quite ready to be promoted.

The Pirates actually won the first game, 8-5, despite the fact that they sent Nick Kingham out to start. Kingham was once considered a potential future star, but that was wishful thinking. Kingham may have a role on a pitching staff somewhere but I am not sure what it is and it sure as heck isn’t as a starter.

This came on the heels of Friday night against the Dodgers when the Pirates went with this “opener” nonsense and designated Michael Feliz to start the game. It shouldn’t have shocked anyone that Feliz got bombed and the game quickly became a blowout that ended as a 10-2 loss.

It is true the Pirates have been the victim of a rash of injuries. They are without their two best starters, Trevor Williams and Jameson Taillon. They have been without one of their best relievers in Keone Kela. They are trying to piece things together until they can get healthy, and that’s why the pitching staff currently is a mess.

Advertise with us

The injuries are a product of bad luck and they are a reason that the Pirates are in this predicament. The injuries are not the only reason, though. They have had bad luck, but it has been compounded by bad management and poor planning.

I’ve heard things such as “Nobody could have seen two starters going down together so early in the season” as a rationalization for what has transpired, but that is excuse-making. This mess is also a result of a total dereliction of duty by the front office. Injuries happen, especially to pitchers. The fact that the Pirates left themselves with zero margin for error is on the front office and nobody else.

The Pirates entered the season bragging about their pitching depth. They talked about how they had seven starters capable of pitching at this level, but most people knew that was wishful thinking.

The staff had two sure things — Williams and Taillon. But given Taillon’s injury history, it shouldn’t have come as a surprise that he is on the 60-day injured list. That’s bad luck, but it is also is something the Pirates should have planned for. That’s especially true considering the other three rotation pitchers — Chris Archer, Joe Musgrove and Jordan Lyles — all had questions hanging over their heads.

The Pirates front office told us Steven Brault and Kingham were quality depth pitchers. That was a hard sell to start the season and it is an impossible one now.

Advertise with us

I’ve heard all the explanations about how hard it is to find pitching depth and how Brault and Kingham aren’t much different than any other staff’s sixth and seventh starter. Just for kicks, I looked up the 2014 Pirates’ statistics to see what the depth pitchers on a playoff team looked like. The Pirates needed seven starters to get through the season (seven made 10 or more starts) and the two “depth” pitchers were Vance Worley and Brandon Cumpton.

Nobody would classify Worley or Cumpton as great pitchers. They were exactly what the Pirates needed them to be — depth pitchers — and they are the kinds of pitchers a lot of staffs have in that position.

Huntington was recently asked why the he hasn’t aggressively tried to make the rotation better. He answered with his typical trite nonsense about how the “back of the baseball cards” of other guys that are available might look better than Brault and Kingham’s, but that doesn’t mean they are upgrades. Someone needs to explain to Huntington that the main reason the “back of baseball cards” of some players look better than others is mostly because they are better players.

That is why I don’t buy that the Pirates’ situation is 100% because of injuries. Injuries have hurt, but they have been compounded by the fact that the Pirates didn’t leave themselves any margin for error and have refused to be aggressive in trying to correct their mistakes. Huntington needs to fix this as soon as possible or he won’t have to worry about making a trade deadline acquisition, because the Pirates will be out of the race by then.