Jeff Capel came to Pitt with a reputation as a great recruiter. And there is no question the 44-year-old seems to have the skill set required to be that — charismatic, energetic, passionate, etc. — and can relate to players.

That being said, he isn’t a miracle worker, and he wasn’t going to take Pitt’s recruiting to the next level in one year. Many fans seem to be upset that Capel hasn’t been able to land any of the high-profile players he has recruited. He hasn’t been able to land that top 25 or even top 50 player this year, and those are the kinds of players who turn a program around in a hurry.

That is really unfair to Capel, who, by the way, has done a nice job of recruiting players who will help Pitt win games. Sure, he hasn’t brought in the top-10 players he routinely landed at Duke, but I’m thinking the fact that he had “Duke” on his shirt and Coach K to close the deal helped a bit.

Pitt’s basketball brand was strong under Ben Howland and in the early parts of the Jamie Dixon era. The Panthers were a fixture in the NCAA Tournament, and because they played with a bit of an old school tenacity, they were often favorites of the former coaches turned broadcasters. Pitt was known as the program for tough-minded, city kids who refuse to lose and do all the little things well.

Advertise with us

That started to change near the end of Dixon’s time here, and that’s when the brand began to take a hit. Dixon’s last three seasons at Pitt were underwhelming based on the standards he himself set. The program became somewhat stale and was closing in on mediocre and irrelevant, and that was reflected in the lack of interest and declining attendance.

Dixon left for TCU and that brought on the Kevin Stallings era, and there is no other way to classify that other than to say it was a total disaster.

Capel is now entering his second year. He has been asked to resurrect the dead, and some people don’t seem to understand that this isn’t going to be an easy task. The brand had slowly but surely eroded over a five- or six-year period, and I don’t care how good Capel, or any coach, is — that isn’t going to be erased in one recruiting cycle.

That brings me back to Capel’s ability to recruit at Pitt. He has prided himself on the fact that he can get into the homes of the four- and five-star recruits who are ranked highly, players to whom, traditionally, a school like Pitt had no prayer of even talking. He has been able to do that quite often, actually, and that has raised expectations to an unrealistic level.

Capel hasn’t yet closed the deal on one of those players, but being in on them is a huge step forward for the program. Capel has already spent a year recruiting players for the next two classes, and that will make a big difference. He has built relationships with the 2020 and 2021 players and has even begun to introduce Pitt to the top 2022 players. That will give him an opportunity to have a fair shot to recruit those players because he will have built a relationship that has lasted longer than 10 months.

Advertise with us

I also suspect Pitt’s on-court product will improve over the next two years, and that will help Capel make the case to big-time players that Pitt is on the rise again.

Winning matters in recruiting. Relationships matter in recruiting. A brand matters in recruiting.

Capel hasn’t had nearly enough time to produce a winner, rebuild the brand or build the kinds of relationships necessary to win hotly contested recruiting battles. But fans should give him time to do what he needs to do before criticizing him for not being able to close the deal with blue chippers and program changers.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise