The Pirates are on the cutting edge. They have been way ahead of the curve in the way they have used advanced statistics, analytics and technology to their advantage. They have a sleep program, a rest program, a nutrition program and a program for just about every other aspect of their players’ lives.

All of it is designed to get the maximum performance out of every player and aimed at injury prevention. It has all been written about and discussed at large for at least the last eight years, and all of it is very interesting.

But it is meaningless if you aren’t smart enough to do something as simple as manage a roster or a game. And Wednesday was yet another example of how the Pirates have gotten full of themselves and their level of intelligence, and far too often they outsmart themselves.

That’s why the Pirates are sort of like that nerdy kid in high school with exemplary grades who couldn’t do the most basic things because he lacked common sense. We used to say to those kids, “You are the dumbest smart kid I know,” and that is an apt description of the Pirates.

Advertise with us

On Wednesday, it cost the Pirates a game because they were short-handed and didn’t need to be. They refuse to go beyond their chart graphs and analytics to use certain pitchers who could have helped them win the game.

It started Monday, when it became clear that Steven Brault and Nick Kingham would have to pitch on back-to-back days due to injuries to Jameson Taillon and Chris Archer. With those two pitching on back-to-back days, it was obvious they would need relief help.

Keone Kela has had a sore arm and had been shut down for several days. The Pirates presumably knew this since, well, they have the cutting-edge programs that monitor everything their players do. That being the case, why didn’t the Pirates have someone like Clay Holmes on standby and ready to step in if Kela had to go on the injured list?

Clint Hurdle was asked about this after the game and said something about hindsight being “20/15.” That’s a funny line but it is total nonsense and an insult to anyone who has paid attention. It didn’t take a genius or math formula to understand they needed to make sure they had a backup plan ready to go.

Kela went on the injured list after the game and Holmes was called up, but it was too late to win a very winnable game against a bad team.

Advertise with us

That brings us into the actual game when the rest formula basically sacked the Pirates’ chances of winning. The Pirates led 6-2 going into the seventh inning and had Francisco Liriano on the mound. He breezed through the inning in 14 pitches, so the easy move would be to let him pitch the eighth. But he had thrown 55 pitches in two outings, so the team decided to shut him down.

This is where you ask Liriano, “How do you feel?” And if he says “fine,” you allow him to go out and at least start to pitch the eighth. Instead, Hurdle brought in Michael Feliz, and that’s never a good option. While he did record two outs, he also walked the bases loaded. That brought up Hunter Pence, perhaps the Rangers’ hottest hitter right now, and that meant it was time to get Feliz the heck out of the game.

That is when Hurdle should have used Felipe Vazquez for one batter, but he refuses to use his closer outside of the ninth inning and not in a save situation. Pence hit a grand slam off Feliz and the rest is history.

The good news is Vazquez and Kyle Crick will now be available Thursday night against St. Louis. In other words, Thursday’s game was apparently more important than Wednesday’s game. And that is flat-out dumb because there is no way to know how Thursday’s game will unfold. Joe Musgrove could pitch a complete game and Hurdle won’t need Vazquez or Crick.

The Pirates have made themselves a model organization because of their intelligence and use of analytics. They have indeed been on the cutting edge in a lot of ways. The problem is they believe they are smarter than they actually are and that their programs trump reality no matter what, and it is costing them games.