There are a lot of complaints about this year’s NCAA basketball tournament, and all of them center around the idea that there aren’t enough upsets. People love the little guy, the Cinderella and the idea of David beating Goliath.
Pardon me if I tell those people just how misguided they are. You can have a tournament loaded with Cinderellas and upsets; I’ll take this year’s tournament every time.
I like chalk. I love the idea of the best teams playing for the most prestigious title the sport has to offer. I like the idea of watching the teams who have had the best seasons rewarded by getting a chance to play on the second weekend and beyond.
There were 14 of the top 16 seeds who advanced to the Sweet 16. The two teams that advanced from outside the top 16 were Auburn and Oregon, and the beauty of that is both are tournament champions from Power 5 conferences. That means there is no Cinderella in the Sweet 16; there isn’t really even a heavy underdog.
It would have been surprising if Oregon advanced to the Final Four but then again, they did win the Pac-12 conference tournament so maybe not. I don’t care that it was a down year in the Pac-12; any team that wins the conference tournament of a Power 5 league is good enough — and deserving enough — to win the national title.
Sure, Duke and North Carolina are the two favorites and there isn’t any George Mason or VCU in the field to pull off a shocking second-weekend upset, and that’s just fine by me. I don’t mind an upset or two early in the tournament, but by the second weekend I want to see the best teams and the best players.
I am convinced those people who love the little guy aren’t real basketball fans. They are the casual fans that come out every March because someone at the office hustled $5 out of them to fill out a pool. Those people watch the games on the first day or two, but they aren’t invested in the long haul of three weekends.
A true basketball fan wants to see the best teams and understands why they are the best teams. A true basketball fan doesn’t want to watch hours of nonstop Sister Jean footage and all the other stuff that is shoved down our throats when one of these little guys makes a run.
One thing that seems to get lost in all of the bracket foolishness and that “One Shining Moment” song is that this tournament decides the national champion. This is the playoffs. This is the supposed to showcase the sport’s best teams and reward the teams that have truly had the best seasons.
I’ve often maintained that the college football playoff system is far closer to correct than the NCAA tournament. The football playoff may exclude a team here or there and may leave room for debate about who should be No. 4 and who is No. 5. But all four teams who make it into the college football playoffs are being rewarded for having elite seasons. There aren’t any mediocre teams in the college football playoffs. There aren’t any teams who haven’t earned the right to be there. There aren’t any teams who are there because there are so many spots to fill that somebody needs to fill them.
The NCAA Tournament would be a lot better if it went down to 48 teams and cut it to 28 automatic bids. That would ensure that we could get rid of a bunch of teams who have no business playing for the national title. You know who you are Oklahoma, Ohio State, Syracuse and Arizona State. Those teams had nice seasons and they should have all been rewarded with a trip to the NIT or the CBI.
All of that is why this NCAA tournament is one of the best I can remember despite all the moaning about its lack of “drama”. I’ll turn on A&E if I want drama and I’ll go to the theater district if I want to watch Cinderella. I want to watch the best teams compete at the highest level on the biggest stage, and I want the team that is crowned champion at the end to actually be worthy of it.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.