The Penguins are headed down the home stretch toward the playoffs, and the only thing abundantly clear about them is we still have no idea who they are at this point.
They could be Stanley Cup champions in a few months, but they could also be a team that goes into the tank and misses the playoffs altogether. And if you said they were anything in between those two extremes, I wouldn’t argue with you.
The Penguins quite simply have no identity, at least not one that sticks around for more than 15 minutes. This is a team that has remade itself so many times this season it is hard to figure out which version will show up at the rink from night to night. There doesn’t seem to be a plan, doesn’t seem to be an overall direction and, more importantly, there doesn’t seem to be any consistency — from the general manager down to the last player on the roster.
The Penguins are frustrating to follow and even more frustrating to watch. I can’t imagine what it is like to root for the Penguins because they are so schizophrenic in so many ways. One night they look like world beaters who might go 16-0 in the playoffs, and the next night they lay an egg against a bad team.
We saw this act in the fall from the Steelers, by the way, and their season had a disastrous ending. The Steelers looked unstoppable some weeks then lost to teams like the Raiders and Broncos with their season on the line. They ended up missing the playoffs, and all hell has broken loose with that team since.
I do expect the Penguins to make the playoffs, so they aren’t likely to repeat the Steelers’ dubious season in that regard. I also don’t expect Sidney Crosby to show up on social media sporting a blonde mustache and referring to himself as Big Chest, or some obscure former player claiming Marc-Andre Fleury once intentionally let a puck go into the net, either. The Penguins don’t have the Steelers’ drama, but they are similar in that they are an incredibly talented team that can’t get out of its own way at times.
Read More
The Flyers game Sunday was a microcosm of the Penguins’ season. The Penguins were excellent, borderline dominant for 59 minutes and should have been ahead by far more than one goal. Flyers goalie Carter Hart was sensational and stood tall despite facing 42 shots from the Penguins.
The Penguins were in complete control and headed for two important points. Then in the final minute, instead of securing the puck in the neutral zone, they went empty-net goal hunting, turned it over and James Van Riemsdyk tied the game with 19 seconds to play. Sidney Crosby then made a rare mistake with the puck with less than 10 seconds to play in overtime, and Sean Couturier stole it and beat Matt Murray for the game winner with three seconds left.
That is sort of the story of the Penguins, though, isn’t it? And that is why the Penguins are still scrambling to secure a playoff berth with only nine games remaining.
The Penguins play a huge game Tuesday night at Carolina, and if they lose, things start to get a little dicey for them. They follow that with three road games in a row and then return home to face the Hurricanes.
The Penguins need to find an identity and stick to it and play consistently well for 60 minutes a night. It is easier said than done, but this is a team that knows how to win Stanley Cup championships and knows the grind of the playoffs.
Injuries are obviously going to play a role in how the Penguins finish, and they have certainly played a role in their maddening inconsistency. Kris Letang is day-to-day but has seemingly been out so long it feels more like month-to-month. Evgeni Malkin is week-to-week with his injury. Oli Maata has been out. Mike Sullivan has had to scramble to fill holes and there is no doubt that is a factor.
But the injuries won’t matter if the Penguins’ best players —and that includes Murray — don’t all get on the same page and start to play at a high level consistently. The pieces are in place for the Penguins to be an outstanding hockey team, but we have seen very little evidence they can be that team four games in a row, much less four playoff series in a row against good teams.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.