Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Marty Carisco, Lawrenceville: Are the Pirates playoff contenders as currently constructed? If they are close to the top of the division at the trade deadline, will they make a deal for whatever they need to get over the top?
Zeise: I don’t think they are playoff contenders as they are currently constructed. I think they have some good pieces in place, but they aren’t there yet. They need to add something at the trade deadline. I do think that they have a good core of players and aren’t that far away, but given their division, it might take 90 wins to get to the playoffs. This team looks to be more of an 82- to 84-win team than an 88- to 90-win team. And that’s just not going to be good enough to get to the playoffs. Now, obviously, if Jung Ho Kang and Josh Bell combine for about 55 homers and Gregory Polanco gets back quickly and has another good season at the plate, things could change. But that’s asking a lot. The Pirates have a solid foundation of young talent and pitching and should be competitive. I just think asking this team to get to the playoffs is probably one bridge too far.
Jason Morenan, Sewickley: If you were the Pirates, what current pre-arbitration player would you offer a deal (to buy out the rest of their arbitration years and buy a few more yeas of control) like they gave to McCutchen or Marte?
Zeise: Jameson Taillon and Trevor Williams. I think it makes sense for the Pirates because it would ensure they have a really good one-two punch at the top of their rotation for five or six years. And I think it would make sense for Taillon, too, given his age (27) and injury history. He won’t be a free agent until he is 31 and at that point he isn’t likely to cash in on the mega deal he would get if he were 27 or 28 and a free agent. The two sides should be working on this deal as we speak because it is a win-win. Williams is a little less of a priority, but if you can lock him up, too, that would be a good development for the immediate future of the team.
Read More
Jeff Atkins, Squirrel Hill: Steelers G.M. Kevin Colbert has stated that he's not just giving Antonio Brown away. However, will he have a choice if all the interested teams low-ball him with offers knowing he has to get rid of A.B.?
Zeise: He has no choice, and he knows it. There is no way Brown can come back and be a Steelers player. He has torched all of his bridges with the team, torched his bridge with the coach and put his quarterback on blast. The Steelers have to trade him and they know it. He is simply saying they won’t give him away because he is trying to salvage Brown’s trade value. I don’t know what his trade value is, but if anyone offers them a third-round pick or higher, they need to take it and move on. They have money to sign a free-agent wide receiver and shedding this headache will be addition by subtraction.
Greg Ranlode, Erie: I know you are an NBA fan by listening to your show and even though NBA isn’t in Pittsburgh I’d like to know your opinion of LeBron James going to the Lakers and what has happened since he arrived?
Zeise: It has been an unmitigated disaster, and frankly this could hurt his legacy. He is clearly not happy, his teammates aren’t happy with him, he isn’t even trying in many games (see Twitter and YouTube for proof), and I don’t see how it will get better in the offseason. LeBron should have finished his career in Cleveland and he will regret leaving. He had it all in Cleveland and left for all the wrong reasons. It is actually a lesson a certain disgruntled wide receiver from the Steelers could learn, to be honest.
George Woods, Delmont: At the start of the season you predicted the Pitt men's basketball team would win 4-5 ACC games. It doesn't look like they will accomplish that. If they don't, would you consider this season to be a disappointment, even though it is Year 1 of another rebuild?
Zeise: I think the season will be a disappointment if they don’t get to three wins. That would mean they are finishing on a 14-game losing streak, and that isn’t good by any measure. The key there is you’d hope Jeff Capel would find a way to get the team out of this funk at least once or twice down the stretch. Either way, it isn’t that big of a deal because Capel won’t and shouldn’t be judged on anything that happens. He is going to recruit well and once he gets his players in, that is when it matters in terms of the wins and losses. There has been a solid foundation built with the three freshmen, so there has been some good to come out of this season.
Harold in Washington: I listened to your show and you talked about a shot clock in high school basketball. I understand what you are saying about making the game better to watch but I don’t agree it will make players better. Why do you think a shot clock will be good for players’ development?
Zeise: It will force players to learn how to play offense as opposed to run offense. It will force players to learn how to create their own shots as opposed to always needing a scheme or set to get open. That’s a huge difference. And the more players learn to play with a shot clock, the better they will have to become at getting their own shot. Right now there is way too much micromanaging by coaches in high school basketball and it is killing the game. And teams trying to delay games in order to pull an upset is ridiculous. A shot clock forces everyone to learn how to play offense and that makes the game and the players better.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.