Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Martin Carinsty, Lawrenceville: I’ve read a number of reports that place Antonio Brown’s value in a trade at something less than a first-round pick. How is that possible? Teams should be lining up to sign a player of his talent with his production. What do you think the Steelers should hold out for before they trade him?
Zeise: In light of these newest allegations of a domestic dispute, I’d think his value is almost nothing. Seriously. Who wants this guy on their team? Maybe a team like the Bengals, but now that Marvin Lewis is gone, I’d be willing to bet even that team will try to have a better culture. I keep hearing about Brown’s talent — and he is an incredibly talented football player. But it takes more to win than talent, and in his case, he is far more of a distraction and nuisance than he is worth. He is a selfish player who seems to be worried more about everything except winning. If I were Art Rooney II, I’d quote former Eagles coach Buddy Ryan when asked about trading Earnest Jackson: “I’d trade him for a six pack and it doesn’t even have to be cold.” The bottom line is the Steelers need to get whatever they can for him and move on. I will be shocked if he brings in more than a third-round pick at this point.
Fellx Caste, Pittsburgh: I’ve seen all the Steeler qbs from Jimmy Finks to Ben. Who do you think are the five best qbs in Steeler history and in what order? Mine are Bradshaw, Ben, Layne, O’Donnell, Kordell. Sorry Bubby.
Zeise: I can only go by the quarterbacks I have actually seen play. And while I am an old fogey, I’m not that old! The five best in my lifetime in order are: Ben Roethlisberger, Terry Bradshaw, Neil O’Donnell, Bubby Brister and Tommy Maddox. I also think Kordell Stewart was better than he got credit for, so I will say he was 5B.
Read More
Roger Littleberry, @relgreyhound: If the Steelers have so much talent, in your opinion, of the 22 starters how many could start for other NFL teams?
Zeise: I think every offensive starter (if we are talking about last year’s lineup and going with Smith-Schuster, Brown, McDonald, Nix and Conner as the skill-position players) could start for other NFL teams. I think the three defensive linemen could all start on other teams. TJ Watt and Vince Williams could start on other NFL teams. Joe Haden could start on other NFL teams. That’s 17 of the 22 starters. And I would be willing to bet there is one or two more that could, as well. The offense is better than the defense, no doubt, but talent wasn’t the Steelers’ problem.
Michael Oleniacz, @MikeOlen1231: If the Patriots were not in the NFL ... how many rings would the Steelers have? The Steelers are the Phil Mickelson of the NFL.
Zeise: They have lost three times to the Patriots in the playoffs since the start of this Bill Belichick/Tom Brady run. I don’t know that I would have picked any of those three teams to win the Super Bowl even if they had gotten past the Patriots. The 2001 team had a mediocre quarterback. The 2004 team had Roethlisberger, but it was his first year. The 2016 team was terrible in the secondary and on defense and I think would have gotten picked apart by Matt Ryan and the Falcons.
Matt B, @talisker66: Given where they're at now (12-11, 2-8, but with a softer ACC schedule to finish), what is a successful season for Pitt men's basketball?
Zeise: They have already had success on some level. I think they just need to win a few more games so that it doesn’t appear like the bottom fell completely out. They have regressed a little bit, but that’s to be expected. It is a tough league for a team led by freshmen and lacking depth and size. I think as long as they win at least two more games it should be considered an extremely successful season.
Pirates Trump, @TrumpPirates: What's your guess on win total for the Pirates this year?
Zeise: I think 83 sounds about right. They have some holes in their lineup but a good pitching staff. And by the way, I happen to think you are one of the most entertaining Twitter follows on the internet. Your takes on the Pirates are hilarious. Keep being you.
LincolnEps324, @LEps324: Should the #HalftimeShow change it up? No more musicians.
Zeise: I have no idea. I am an old crotchety man and don’t care about the halftime show or the commercials. That stuff is just to make the game appeal to a broader audience of people who aren’t hardcore football fans. They can do whatever they want, I still will get up and go fix myself a plate to eat and not watch the TV during halftime.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.