There might actually be some legitimate reasons to be optimistic that the Pirates will return to the playoffs this season, and I’ve spent the last few weeks trying to convince myself of them.

But every time I try to make the realistic case that they are headed back to the playoffs, I am snapped back to reality. The Pirates look a lot like a team that is destined to finish in fourth place again. The Pirates’ over/under for wins has been set at 78 1/2, and quite frankly, that feels about right.  I could easily see a few things go wrong or a couple of players regress for the Pirates to end up a 75-76 team. I could also see the Pirates have a bunch of things go right and end up with 83-84 wins.

And therein lies the Pirates’ biggest problem: Their best-case scenario still does not add up to more than another fourth-place finish in the National League Central. I suppose I should qualify that by adding the word “realistic” to best-case scenario because I am sure there are many Armageddon-like scenarios people could concoct that lead to the Pirates winning it all. So let’s just say absent of the ridiculous “Jung-Ho Kang and Josh Bell combine for 75 HRs, Jordan Lyles becomes a dominant fifth starter and the Cardinals, Cubs and Brewers all have a rash of injuries” scenarios, the Pirates aren’t likely to make a move in a loaded division.

Where they finish in the division is far more significant to me than the Pirates’ win total. I picked them to win 79 games last year. They won 82 and had a winning record. They sure showed me, although there isn’t much of a difference between 79 and 82 wins, other than the ability to brag about a non-losing season.

Advertise with us

That’s all wonderful news, except they were picked to finish fourth in the NL Central almost universally and that’s exactly where they finished. And the other three teams that were ahead of them aren’t coming back to them any time soon. So in order to make the playoffs this season, the Pirates needed to make some tangible and legitimate improvements in the offseason, and instead they have done almost nothing.

It is fair, then, to ask the question where exactly the necessary improvement is coming from. Kang could come in and hit 25 to 30 home runs and Bell could bounce back and hit for more power, as well. I suppose Lyles could become a competent fifth starter and do better than pitchers like Tyler Glasnow and Nick Kingham did in that spot last season. And a whole season of Chris Archer and Joe Musgrove in the rotation — assuming both are healthy and can duplicate what we saw from them in 2018 — could be an area of improvement, as well.

If that all happens, it adds up to maybe five or six more wins at most. That puts the Pirates at about 87-88 wins and that still isn’t good enough to lift them out of fourth place. The Cardinals finished with 88 wins last season and they added two significant players in the offseason. The Brewers and Cubs both won 95 games (technically the Brewers won 96 but that includes the extra game with the Cubs to determine the division champion), and neither of those two teams is likely to take a step back. The Cubs are actually likely to be a little better this season because a number of their best players had down years at the plate.

To get to their 87-88 wins, the Pirates will need to get the same performances from their key players that they did last year. And that isn’t likely to happen, as we will likely see some regression.

And it means the Pirates’ pitching staff would have to stay incredibly healthy again with Trevor Williams and Jameson Taillon duplicating what they did last season and Felipe Vazquez being dominant again. It means Francisco Cervelli stays healthy enough to play 100-plus games and duplicates his numbers from last year (which, along with 2015, was a career year). It means Gregory Polanco is back in the lineup quickly and again posts the power numbers he had last season. Corey Dickerson also had an excellent season both at the plate and in the field, and Adam Frazier would need to hit well again and continue to improve as a fielder.

Advertise with us

Kevin Newman, the likely everyday shortstop, will also have to improve at the plate significantly just to duplicate what the Pirates got from Jordy Mercer last season. Newman is a better fielder than Mercer, so perhaps the Pirates gain something minimal there.

In short, the Pirates are once again hoping a whole lot of things go right, some things go uncharacteristically right and a number of things go wrong for the three teams they are chasing. It’s hard for me to get on board with the idea that this is now a playoff team.

The Pirates have not done much to actually improve themselves, and as they say in the military, hope is not a method.