Antonio Brown is the best wide receiver in the NFL, probably the best wide receiver in Steelers history and in the discussion for the best of all time.
Brown has helped them win a lot of games, some almost single-handedly with big receptions only he can make. Ben Roethlisberger acknowledged on his radio show this week that he needed Brown saying “he makes me better.”
It used to be clear that the Steelers are better with Brown than they’d be without him. Now, I’m not sure that’s the case. It seems incidents that are destructive to the team have increased in frequency over the past two or three seasons.
Brown basically didn’t show up for work. By the time he did, he’d forced Mike Tomlin’s hand. I give Tomlin credit, by the way, for holding the line; the game against the Bengals was of the must-win variety and Brown would have helped to that end.
Many of Brown’s indiscretions have been overblown, and some have had little do with football, but others — like running the wrong routes when he was upset about his usage — are a real problem.
Brown has been selfish at times, but his ability and performance meant he got a lot more leeway than most players. The Steelers and Tomlin have, in some ways, been his enablers but how many other teams — including the Patriots — would bring the hammer down on arguably their best player?
Read More
Do you believe Bill Belichick would have suspended Brown for a playoff game or gotten rid of him? I don’t. Belichick is in the business of winning. Now, if you want to argue that Belichick would have been able to handle Brown better than Tomlin, I might listen. If you want to say the Patriots’ culture would have won Brown over, I might listen to that, as well. Just don’t tell me Belichick would have kicked Brown off the team.
The Steelers have given Brown more chances than he has deserved — but they had to. He is too good a player to put on a short leash. Brown’s emotional nature also meant that they had to give him the benefit of the doubt. Tomlin would allow Brown’s tantrums to play out, then deal with him on a more rational level.
All of that being said, Brown has now put the Steelers in a terrible situation — maybe at the point of no return. So, the team has to seriously weigh all of its options.
It is easy to say the Steelers should trade him, but that isn’t as simple as it sounds. Ed Bouchette laid out how his salary cap hit is manageable and not prohibitive to a deal.
That doesn’t change the fact that the Steelers are not likely to get a player of close to equal value in return. The most likely return is a first-round pick, with maybe a couple later-round picks thrown in. That is good for the future, but this is a team that has to be thinking about winning right now. Roethlisberger will be 37 next season. At some point his skills will decline.
A rookie isn’t likely to help immediately, and it is hard to imagine the Steelers getting a veteran that impacts games as much as Brown. That is usually the case when a star is traded.
There is also the impact that trading Brown will have on the offense — especially without Le’Veon Bell in the backfield. We saw a glimpse of that Sunday at Heinz Field against an awful Bengals team, and it wasn’t pretty. JuJu Smith-Schuster has been amazing as the No. 2 receiver. Would he be as dynamic if he had to move over and become No. 1? Brown draws double teams, brackets and all kinds of junk defenses, which creates more room for the other receivers to run.
That’s why the Steelers are just left of a rock and just right of a hard place. No matter how they decide to proceed with Brown, it has a chance to turn out to be a disaster.
Brown’s talent has allowed Tomlin and the Steelers to turn a blind eye to some of his shenanigans, but they seem to know they can’t enable him any more. They need to figure out the next step. The best way to do that is to answer the question, “are we still better with Brown and all of his nonsense than we would be without him?”
The answer to that question used to be clear. It’s not any longer, and it is up to the Steelers to figure it out.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.