JuJu Smith-Schuster was voted by his teammates as the Steelers’ MVP Thursday. Smith-Schuster has had an excellent season, and on the surface it would seem like he is a legitimate candidate for this kind of honor.
Some think Ben Roethlisberger was snubbed and should earn the honor every single season. He’s having an excellent 2018, but he’s also thrown 15 interceptions in a season that might end Sunday.
Now let’s be frank: The award is fairly meaningless, so much so that a number of teams don’t even name an MVP.
That being said, how in the world did Smith-Schuster win? I don’t know if Roethlisberger should have won, but I do know this — if it was going to go to a receiver, it should be Antonio Brown.
Smith-Schuster is clearly a talented young player and has had a great season. He leads the Steelers in receptions (106) and receiving yards (1,389) and is second to only Jesse James in yards per reception (13.1 ypc). He has made some huge plays and has been tremendous off the field and in the community as well.
Let’s not lose our minds, though, about where he fits in the hierarchy of Steelers receivers
Read More
JuJu Smith-Schuster thanks teammates for MVP honor
Brown is clearly the Steelers’ best receiver, and it isn’t even close. Brown not only is the Steelers’ best wideout, but he may actually be the team’s best football player as well.
Smith-Schuster is talented but he wouldn’t have had the numbers he put up this year if it wasn’t for Brown. Every team game plans to stop Brown, and that usually requires more than one player. He gets double teamed and bracketed, and teams have made it clear they are going to make someone else on the Steelers beat them.\
Let’s refer to Broncos coach Vance Joseph’s comments after Denver’s 24-17 upset the Steelers a few weeks back:
“Our game plan was not to let Antonio Brown [beat us],” Joseph told reporters. “We knew ‘19,’ Schuster, was going to make some plays obviously, but the plan was not to let ‘84’ beat us. I’ve been in games where he’s beaten me single-handedly. The plan was to take him away, stop the run game as best we could with a seven-man box and just deal with ‘19’ the best we could.”
I’m quite sure that’s how many teams approach the Steelers. They are willing to live with what Smith-Schuster, Vance McDonald and Ryan Switzer and everyone else might do, but they aren’t going to let Brown do his thing.
And guess what — Brown still does his thing. He also has caught more touchdown passes (15) than Smith-Schuster (6), Vance McDonald (4), Jesse James (2), Ryan Switzer (1) and James Washington (1) combined. Brown has only two fewer receptions than Smith-Schuster and 91 fewer receiving yards.
There is one other thing about Brown that Smith-Schuster and even Roethlisberger can’t claim: He hasn’t made a costly mistake in a game the Steelers lost.
Roethlisberger may or may not have been snubbed by his teammates, but he at least didn’t lose the award to his No. 2. That’s essentially what happened to Brown, and that’s a crime given everything he means to the Steelers and their offense.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.