Former Steelers and Patriots punter Josh Miller has often told the story about the aftermath of one of the games in which the Patriots played poorly and lost. He said Bill Belichick made sure to parade all of the free agents he was giving a tryout to — and there was at least one for every position — on the practice field as the team was coming off the field.

The message was received loud and clear by the players, and they responded with a big win the next week. That was just one of many tactics Belichick would use to motivate the players, serving as a reminder that all of them were replaceable.

That seems like an appropriate story given that the Steelers are getting ready to play the Patriots, who are coming off an ugly loss to the Dolphins. There may or may not be a parade of free agents flooding Patriots practices this week, but according to Mike Tomlin, there will be some tryouts held at the Steelers’ South Side facilities.

Chris Boswell was one of the best kickers in the NFL last season and was rewarded with a trip to the Pro Bowl and a five-year, $20 million contract. He has struggled this season, though, and Tomlin said the team will be conducting kicker tryouts this week. That doesn’t mean the Steelers necessarily will cut Boswell, though, as he may emerge as the winner of the tryouts.

Advertise with us

“We acknowledge Chris has struggled; we’re willing to explore options that give us our best option to see that ball go through the uprights, and those options include Chris,” Tomlin said. “The prudent approach includes Chris.”

Boswell has missed six field goals and five extra points this season. In the Steelers’ loss to the Raiders on Sunday, he missed a field-goal attempt in the first half and then slipped and fell on a potential game-tying field goal as time expired.

I think it is great that Boswell will have to earn his job this week. He has potentially cost the Steelers at least one game and he seemingly hasn’t gotten better as the season has progressed. But Boswell also was one of the best players the Steelers had last season, so he deserves the chance to prove he is still the best man for the job.

My only problem with the idea is that Boswell isn’t the only one at the Steelers’ facility who should have to battle free agents to keep a job. Tomlin isn’t on the hot seat, nor should he be, but general manager Kevin Colbert should run a bunch of clock-management experts into the facility and force Tomlin to choose one to be his assistant.

And while we are at it, defensive coordinator Keith Butler and special teams coach Danny Smith should see their potential replacements come through the facility for a tryout. It is true that it isn’t realistic to think you can hold tryouts for coaches, but those two have been as bad at their jobs as Boswell has been at his. The defense has left a lot to be desired and the special teams have been a never-ending and embarrassing comedy of errors.

Advertise with us

Joe Haden has played consistently well and Terrell Edmunds is only a rookie, so he is graded on a different curve. Those two should be able to just focus on getting ready for New England. That being said, how in the world can you justify holding kicker tryouts and not bring in every warm body that has ever played corner or safety for a tryout?

I could make a sound argument that safety Morgan Burnett and corner Mike Hilton had as bad of days as Boswell. The defensive backfield has struggled all season, and that’s been a big reason why the defense has been so inconsistent.

This would be a good week to motivate that group, as they are getting ready to face one of the best who has ever done it in Tom Brady. And I don’t think I need to embarrass the innocent by reciting Brady’s numbers against Tomlin’s Steelers, so let’s just say he has had a lot of success against them.

Tomlin should also bring in a boatload of inside linebackers to try out, as Sunday was not exactly a banner day for that group, either. Vince Williams got beat by Lee Williams for a 3-yard touchdown reception and had a grand total of one tackle.This unit has been inconsistent all season and could use a bit of a wake-up call.

Boswell is clearly a problem, but he isn’t the only one. It is admirable that the Steelers will look at other options at kicker even though Boswell is making a lot of money and it would be an expensive proposition to cut him.

Tomlin shouldn’t stop the tryout train at kicker, though, and he should take a page from Belichick’s book and bring free agents in by the busload. That’s the only fair way to do things.