The hot-stove season of Major League Baseball, when teams that are interested in improving go out and either trade for or sign players that will help, is heating up.
Generally, it is also the season for Pirates fans to become frustrated as they watch their team sit idly by. Eventually, Pirates brass will go to PiratesFest and try to convince their fans that spending in the offseason doesn’t translate to better teams and scoff at the idea that they aren’t trying to improve.
How do I know this will happen again? Mostly because Neal Huntington has already laid the groundwork out for how the Pirates will approach this offseason.
“We went for it aggressively this summer, and the addition of Chris Archer and Keone Kela were two players that we believed would help our 2018 club. Our August didn’t show that,” Huntington told Chris Mueller and Andrew Fillipponi on 93.7 The Fan on Nov. 12. “Our September, we believe did. But we felt that that was the ability to impact our ‘19 and ‘20 clubs as well by making an aggressive move in the summertime. We felt that that was the one access point that we would have to add talent at that level.”
A rough translation: “Can’t you people just be happy we moved some prospects for a big name once this year?”
In other words, the Pirates have made their big deals, and they aren’t interested in making any more. They’ve spent their money.
Read More
Hey, be happy, they did sign Lonnie Chisenhall and essentially renegotiated with Jung-Ho Kang to get him to take less money. Never mind that Chisenhall’s advanced numbers suggest an average hitter with mediocre power, or that Kang has a total of six at-bats in the past two seasons.
Look, I hate to be cynical and criticize the Pirates; they deserve some credit for adding Archer and Kela at deadline. I just won’t fall all over myself to pat them on the back for those moves, because all they really did was operate like a real baseball organization that is truly interested in winning.
That was a refreshing change for the Pirates, though, and those moves helped preserve a winning record for only the fourth time since 1992. I suppose that’s something worth celebrating, but frankly, the only relevant fact is the Pirates didn’t make the playoffs.
That’s why the focus this offseason shouldn’t be on their record, but rather where they finished in the standings: in fourth place in the National League Central behind the Brewers, Cubs and Cardinals. The Pirates finished six games behind the Cardinals and 12 behind the Cubs and Brewers.
Those are the teams the Pirates are chasing. The question shouldn’t be “Did we improve our roster?,” but rather “Did we improve our roster enough to catch and pass at least two — if not all three — of those teams?”
That is what it will take to return to the playoffs, and therefore that should be the Pirates’ measuring stick.
There is no way the Pirates can look their fans and season ticket holders in the eyes and honestly tell them that they’re better than any of those three teams. The same holes the Pirates had this season will continue to exist.
The team they were closest to, the Cardinals, understand that they are falling behind the Brewers and Cubs, so they have made it clear they are going to work hard to improve. They took a great first step toward that Wednesday by trading for Arizona star first baseman Paul Goldschmidt.
Goldschmidt makes the Cardinals’ lineup significantly more dangerous, and as a result they closed the gap with the Brewers and Cubs — and widened it with the Pirates. The Cubs had a disappointing season in that they didn’t win the division, and Theo Epstein has made it clear they will be active this offseason, as well, and the Brewers will again be one of the best teams in the National League next season.
The Pirates, meanwhile, have some real soul-searching to do this offseason. They really aren’t that far away from being legitimate contenders, but to take the next step will require them to stretch a little bit in terms of what they are willing to spend. That goes for money and/or prospects, and Bob Nutting hates spending money while Huntington hates to trade prospects.
This could be an offseason where the Pirates improve a good young core of players and excellent pitching staff. It could be an offseason where they truly close the gap on the three teams they are chasing. It could be the offseason that sets them up for a return trip to the playoffs.
“Could be” is a far cry from “will be,” and given Huntington’s history and his recent comments, it seems as if this will be yet another hot-stove season that irritates Pirates fans and reinforces the idea that winning is not the organization’s top priority.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.