Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Jack Relckert, Monesson: Are the Penguins just in a slump or do they need to rebuild?
Zeise: Wow, this is the million dollar-question right now. Can I answer -- a little bit of both? I mean, it is clear this team has not played its best hockey for weeks. It has been a long time since we have seen this team play a complete game on both ends of the ice. The goaltenders have not exactly played well, either. They have looked slow and disinterested at times. They are, therefore, indeed slumping and just not playing well at all. That being said, I don’t know that they need to rebuild, but they do need to retool. They don’t have enough firepower to win the Stanley Cup right now. They need some more secondary scoring. They need at least one, if not two, better defensemen. They could use a little bit more speed, as well. Clearly they can play better than they have, but they also aren’t quite good enough to win the Stanley Cup and will need some help to get back to becoming a championship-level team.
Greg Taggs, Mt. Lebanon: Did the Penguins make a mistake and keep the wrong goaltender when they had to choose between Marc-Andre Fleury and Matt Murray?
Zeise: This is the ultimate hindsight. It would have been hard to justify keeping the player who was about 10 years older and much more expensive. That’s especially true with Matt Murray coming off back-to-back Stanley Cup wins. And it was also clear that Murray was Mike Sullivan’s choice, and thus there really wasn’t a decision to be made. Fleury is probably the better goalie, but Murray will be fine. He just needs to gather himself, get his confidence back a little and string together some good performances.
Read More
Marty Lawearth, Oakand: Whose turnaround has been more impressive, the Steelers or Pitt?
Zeise: I will say Pitt and only for one simple reason. The Steelers started out slow but people figured with their talent and pedigree they’d turn it on and win the division despite the slow start. They were a team picked by many to win the Super Bowl. Nobody in their right mind wrote them off completely. Their turnaround isn’t really a surprise because this is the team we thought they’d be. I’ll be honest, when Pitt lost to UCF, I wasn’t sure they’d win five games, much less seven. There was no reason really to believe they’d turn it around and come all the way back to win the Coastal. They were also picked to finish fifth in the division, so they weren’t really expected to do much this year. That’s why I would say Pitt’s turnaround was more impressive. It is all about expectations.
George Duckort, Gibsonia: What will the Steelers’ final record be and where will they be in the standings at the end of the season?
Zeise: I will say 11-4-1. I see them losing two more games. The Saints game on the road will be asking a lot. And I have no idea how anyone can pick them to beat the Patriots, seeing as they don’t have any track record of that. I think that will leave them as the AFC North champs and as the No. 3 seed. KC and the Patriots will both finish 12-4 so New England will be the No. 1 and KC the No. 2.
Lawrence Turkone, Ebensburg: What will the loss of Jimmy Morrissey do to Pitt’s offensive line? Will it affect their ability to beat Miami this week?
Zeise: It could be a huge loss given how well the Pitt offensive line has played. It usually takes time for offensive lines to come together, so the chemistry will be disrupted. That being said, Connor Dintino is an experienced player, so he should step in and be able to handle the duties at center just fine. The larger question will be how does Bryce Hargrove hold up at guard, since he has a lot less experience than Dintino? I think the Miami game is going to be a real handful anyway, as the Hurricanes haven’t played well but have a lot of talent. And that front seven is ridiculously good, so Pitt’s offensive line will have to play well in order to give them a chance to win.
Nate Throm, Pittsburgh: Is there anything to take away from the Pitt men's basketball team's start other than "it's early," or "look at who they've played"?
Zeise: Well, their first test was the Saint Louis game and I’d say they held up very well. They play Iowa next and that is probably asking too much as the Hawkeyes are strong, especially at home. The thing you can read from Pitt’s 6-0 start is that they are playing a better brand of basketball than last year. They are more athletic. They play more like a team. They defend a hell of a lot better than they did last year. The freshman guards have a really bright future. I don’t know how many ACC wins it will translate into, but I will say this team will be a lot more competitive in ACC games than they were last year. They still have a ways to go, but there is reason for optimism.
Joe Ludon, Erie: Who do you think will win in the pay-per-view match between Tiger and Phil?
Zeise: This is kind of a fun event and it seems like -- if you watched the press conferences this week -- it is becoming a WWE-like event. They are talking about betting on every hole. They are betting $200,000 on the first hole alone. They are talking about all kinds of challenges along the course. I have no idea what is going to happen or what it is going to look like. It should be really fun, though, and if it is a real match, I’m picking Tiger to win. I just don’t know how serious it really will be, as it seems like a money grab more than anything.
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.