Mike Tomlin is often criticized by a segment of the Steelers fan base as being everything from extremely overrated to incredibly incompetent. This despite the fact that Tomlin’s record would suggest he has at least some degree of competence as he’s in his 12th year as Steelers coach and has never had a losing season.
Here is perhaps the most telling thing about Tomlin’s tenure as the Steelers’ coach: The other three teams in the division are all going to be searching for a coach this offseason. And that’s mostly because they can’t keep up with Tomlin and the Steelers. The other three owners in the division understand that to win the AFC North, they need to beat the Steelers consistently, and none of them can.
Actually, let’s back up here: All three of the teams in the division SHOULD be looking for a new coach this offseason, but who the heck knows what will happen in Cincinnati with Marvin Lewis.
The Bengals were so bad Sunday that Fox decided to spare those of us in the AFC North viewing area of having to watch the end of their game with the Saints. The Bengals were a complete dumpster fire in that game, and it was about 45-7 when Fox switched to the Tampa Bay-Washington game. The Bengals ended up losing 51-14, but that’s only because Sean Payton had mercy on them.
In a typical Lewis-like move (i.e. having a complete lack of accountability and passing the blame), he fired Bengals defensive coordinator Teryl Austin and announced he will take over defensive play-calling duties. I can only imagine the spike in ticket sales that will come now that fans know Lewis, who is in his 16th season and still has yet to win a playoff game, is coming to the rescue.
The Bengals are not going to make the playoffs for the third year in a row, and most sensible owners would pull the plug on Lewis. Mike Brown, however, is probably working on an extension as we speak. Lewis should be done in Cincinnati, and unless Brown wants the Bengals to continue to fall behind the Steelers, he will make the change as well.
Read More
Hue Jackson was already fired by the Browns. That isn’t a surprise. But in the Browns’ defense they have been incompetent since 1999, and Jackson was just the latest casualty of that. They, too, can’t seem to beat the Steelers and are a long way behind them in the AFC North race.
Browns general manager John Dorsey seems to have at least some semblance of a plan, and maybe interim coach Gregg Williams will do enough down the stretch to keep the job permanently. On Sunday he put his best foot forward, as the Browns dominated the Falcons, but my guess is he has a long, uphill battle to fight to keep the job.
That brings us to John Harbaugh, who has apparently worn out his welcome in Baltimore. Amazingly, there are some who still think Harbaugh is a better coach than Tomlin, even though Tomlin’s success is a major reason Harbaugh might be out of work in about two months.
Harbaugh is a good coach, and he won’t be unemployed long. But he has missed the playoffs three years in a row, and it is likely he will make that four this season.
Tomlin may not be the perfect coach, but he has been the perfect coach for the Steelers. They have been consistently one of the best teams in the AFC under his watch. They win a lot more than they lose. His players play hard for him, and his message seems to still resonate with veterans in that locker room.
The Steelers are and have been the class of the AFC North throughout most of Tomlin’s career, and until he retires or changes jobs, that isn’t likely to change, no matter who the other three teams hire.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.