It took the Penguins until the third game to finally show up for the 2018-19 season. The Penguins played by far their best and most complete hockey game Thursday night and beat Vegas 4-2.
Thursday’s 4-2 against Vegas wasn’t perfect, though, and the Penguins still have work to do defensively. The Golden Knights peppered the Penguins with 37 shots, which is still way too many, and that’s especially true because a number of them were from the dangerous areas on the ice around the goal.
Vegas actually should have probably scored a couple of more goals, except they were stoned by Casey DeSmith, the Penguins backup goalie who was thrust into action because of Matt Murray’s concussion. DeSmith had 35 saves and played far better Thursday than Murray did in either of the first two games.
Mike Sullivan said DeSmith played an excellent game and really was the biggest factor in the Penguins’ win. That’s a pretty bold statement considering Phil Kessel had a natural hat trick and Evgeni Malkin assisted on three of the four goals.
“I thought [DeSmith] was the best player on the ice,” Sullivan said. “He made some great saves for us, especially in that third period. He made some real timely saves for us.”
At least for one night, DeSmith showed he may just be able to play at an elite level. That isn’t a surprise to Jim Rutherford or Sullivan, who have both expressed full confidence in both of the Penguins young goaltenders, DeSmith and Tristan Jarry. It was a little bit of a surprise, though, that DeSmith beat out Jarry for the backup spot, but he continues to reward Sullivan’s faith in him.
Read More
DeSmith is humble, though, and was quick to give all the credit for the win to his teammates. He also said the most important thing about Thursday was the victory.
“That was a huge team effort against a really hungry team there in Vegas,” DeSmith said. “We had to play hard to pull one out there. I think that one leaves a good taste in everybody’s mouth there leaving town here tomorrow. It was definitely something to build on.”
Thursday was supposed to showcase Murray and Marc-Andre Fleury, who returned to Pittsburgh for the second time since he was traded in 2017. Vegas, though, was on the second leg of back-to-back games, and Fleury played Wednesday night against the Capitals. That meant Thursday was his night to sit and rest, and combined with Murray’s concussion, fans were treated to DeSmith vs Malcolm Subban.
It was no doubt a disappointment to Penguins fans, who mostly still love Fleury. They gave him a nice ovation before the game as he was the last player to leave the ice after warm-ups. He then raised his stick to return the respect.
But the most relevant goaltender Thursday was DeSmith. And that should be welcome news to the Penguins given Murray’s status. There is no indication Murray’s concussion will keep him out long term, but given his history, the Penguins need to err on the side of caution. They need to make sure they have a legitimate “Plan B” in place because this is a team that could clearly make a run in the Stanley Cup playoffs.
There is some thought that maybe the Penguins should trade for a veteran backup goalie just in case Murray gets injured again late in the season. That could be an option, but we are a long way from the trade deadline, so Rutherford and Sullivan will have plenty of opportunities to see what DeSmith and maybe even Jarry can do before they have to make that decision.
DeSmith got his first opportunity Thursday, and if it were an exam, he would have scored an A-plus.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.