Ben Roethlisberger got his wish when the Steelers parted ways with offensive coordinator Todd Haley after last season. He also got his wish when the Steelers promoted Randy Fichtner from quarterbacks coach to offensive coordinator. It’s clear Fichtner is Roethlisberger’s guy, and as a result he’ll have a lot more say in the offense and play calling.

Roethlisberger said this week the Steelers will run the no-huddle far more frequently than in recent past. Roethlisberger wants to be able to chuck the ball all over the field and throw for big numbers every week like Aaron Rodgers, Tom Brady and Drew Brees.

But this may be an example of “Be careful what you wish for.” It seems like a great plan to let Roethlisberger call plays and operate out of the no-huddle as much as he wants, but the numbers suggest it really isn’t.

Roethlisberger has proven over the course of his career to be increasingly less effective at winning games the more times he throws the ball. The Steelers are 15-37 in games when he has 40 or more attempts, and that includes an 0-6 mark in the postseason.

Advertise with us

For years we were told Haley put the shackles on Roethlisberger and didn’t let him do the things he does best, and Roethlisberger was running an offense that was too conservative for his skill set.

That idea is laughable at best and ridiculous at worst. Roethlisberger’s best seasons all came, for the most part, with Haley calling the plays. He threw for 3,800 yards or more twice in eight seasons before Haley. He did it five of the six seasons Haley was in charge. He threw for 25 touchdowns or more twice in eight seasons before Haley. In the six seasons with Haley, he did it five times. He’s had six seasons of 500 attempts or more and four of them were with Haley calling the plays.

Roethlisberger threw the ball more, for more yards and more touchdowns with Haley calling plays. Haley, however, also reeled Roethlisberger in at times. He got conservative at times because that’s what the situations dictated or more importantly that’s what Mike Tomlin told him to do. He was also brought in to help prolong Roethlisberger’s career by putting together game plans that greatly reduced his sack numbers. That meant more running plays and shorter passing plays, and while those aren’t as sexy as schoolyard scrambles for big throws or deep passing plays, they can be effective and protect a QB. The three seasons Roethlisberger was sacked the least all came under Haley.

Haley saved Roethlisberger from himself. Haley needed to go because his relationship with Roethlisberger had fallen apart and his message had grown stale. But he did a good job while he was here.

Now it appears there is no one to blame for the offense’s failures but Roethlisberger. When it goes well, he should get all the credit, but when plays don’t work or play calls don’t make sense, there is no more “Coach Todd” to blame.

Advertise with us

It’s all on Roethlisberger now.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com