The NFL’s new helmet rule is not ideal. There are definitely issues with the interpretation and application of it, and there are some plays where the rule was applied this preseason that make you scratch your head. Officials need to continue to educate themselves through film study and consultation with the league’s rules committee and get a better understanding of what the rules are designed to legislate out of the league.
The helmet rule, though, is not the end of football as we know it. Please stop with that nonsense. It isn’t going to change the game fundamentally or turn the game into flag football. It isn’t just another rule designed to give an unfair advantage to the offense.
Under the rule, which was approved by NFL owners in March, any time a player lowers his head to strike an opponent on any part of the body, a penalty can be called. More specific language prohibits players from using the helmet to “butt, spear or ram an opponent.”
It is correct thinking by the NFL and an important step toward making the game safer. I’ve read far too many arguments against the rule — like this one — which suggest that football is a dangerous sport and can’t be made safer, so these rules are unnecessary. I can’t think of a dumber argument against any rule in any sport than, “Hey we can’t make it better, so why try?”

The Ryan Clarks, James Harrisons and countless other “old school” players have predictably come out to criticize the rule on social media. Their mentality is that football is a “man’s game.” They think the NFL should get rid of rules like this and go back to the good old days when the sport was full of dirty players and dangerous hits.
That kind of caveman thinking is idiotic. The sport has become safer and will continue to do so. Helmets and mouth guards are safer now, and there are fewer helmet-to-helmet hits and chop blocks, too.
We still see plenty of hard hits and tackles that make highlight reels. The hope is that we also see fewer head and spinal injuries, both immediate and long term, and those goals are noble and correct. To argue otherwise is to be tone deaf to the fact that we have entire generations of football players suffering from the effects of CTE and brain trauma, some of whom are dying young.
The NFL has had to pay millions in settlements and still has lawsuits pending with regards to head trauma and CTE. The league also sees the data and understands it needs to find ways to at least lessen the risk of playing football. A big component of the NFL “ Heads Up Football” campaign a few years ago was stressing proper tackling techniques to high school and youth football players. The idea was to make the sport safer at the youth level by teaching them shoulder tackling.
These rules aren’t going to stop injuries altogether, but perhaps they can reduce them.
Simply put, the NFL helmet rule is a good rule with good intentions, and it isn’t destined to end the sport as we know it.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.