Pirates general manager Neal Huntington conceded Sunday that the Pirates gave up a lot to make the Chris Archer trade happen.

“The opportunity to add a Chris Archer, we have very limited windows to add a pitcher of that caliber,” Huntington said. “We gave up a lot, but we feel like we got a lot in return.”

That’s not exactly a startling revelation; the Pirates gave up two of their top prospects in Austin Meadows and Shane Baz and one of their former top prospects, Tyler Glasnow.

That’s the cost of doing business in baseball. It takes giving up something of value to receive something of value in return. This is why the over-the-top praise heaped on Huntington for making the deal a few weeks ago was silly. He did his job and he did it well, but the deal was a fairly standard one in the grand scheme of things. Teams make deals like this all the time; it just isn’t the kind of deal Huntington has done in the past.

Advertise with us

It will take some time to evaluate the Archer deal because it largely — actually, completely — depends on how he pitches over the next three seasons. He holds the key as to whether or not this was the right deal for the Pirates, and it’s not relevant what the players who went to Tampa Bay do from this point forward.

Glasnow is off to a great start in Tampa Bay, and there’s a chance that when Meadows is back in the majors, he rips the cover off the ball like he did earlier this season for the Pirates.

But Archer is the player the Pirates wanted, and they did what they had to do to get him. The Pirates acquired him so he can be one of their top pitchers. He is a veteran presence on a young but improving pitching staff.

That’s all great in theory, but Archer hasn’t been that dominant pitcher for a few years. He has been underwhelming, to say the least, in his three starts since joining the Pirates but that is such a small sample size that it is almost irrelevant.

The past two seasons, though, is a much larger sample size and Archer’s numbers suggest he is trending in the wrong direction. He was 22-36 from the start of the 2016 season until he was traded by Tampa Bay to the Pirates in July. His ERA was 4.02 in 2016 and 4.07 in 2017, and it was 4.31 in his 17 games for the Rays this season. His WHIP steadily increased as well (from 1.137 in 2015 and 1.385 this season), and his ERA+ (100 in 2016, 101 in 2017 and 94 in 17 starts this season) suggests a very average to below average pitcher.

Advertise with us

This season, in 20 starts, Archer is 4-5 with a 4.49 ERA and a WHIP of 1.423. He has pitched only 110⅓ innings, which means he is averaging fewer than six innings per start. But Huntington was correct to point out that Archer was brought in for the long haul and not just his 10 or 11 starts this season.

Archer has a lot of time to justify the trade. It’s up to him to make people forget about what the Pirates gave up for him. It is up to him to prove the Pirates were right to give away so much to get him. These are things we won’t know, though, until a few years down the road, but the focus should be on what Archer does and not on the players who are no longer here.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com