Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:

Bryan Keefe, @bkeefe9: With the departure of Austin Meadows in the Chris Archer trade and Corey Dickerson’s uncertain future with the Pirates, what are the chances that the front office tries to bring back Cutch in the offseason?

Zeise: That’s an interesting question, and I’m sure fans would love it. I just don’t think it would fit with what the Pirates are trying to do. They are looking forward and trying to build around a good young group of players. It would also make little sense baseball-wise to sign an aging player whose best days are behind him even if the discount was steep. That doesn’t seem to be the way they want to go these days. Corey Dickerson is younger and more productive; why would they let him go and sign McCutchen, other than to take a walk down nostalgia lane? I’m not saying it is impossible, but it would make no sense.

Chad B. Ruffner,, New Alexandria: Do you think we will ever see an automated strike zone in MLB? These umps are getting worse and worse.

Advertise with us

Zeise: I don’t. I think the umpires union is too strong. I also don’t think it’s practical or even good for the game. There are 300-plus pitches or so in an average game. Umpires probably miss at most seven or eight pitches, and usually only one or two of those at most are egregious. The others are really close and could go either way. I’ll live with the fact that umpires do a great job of usually getting it right. They are right far more often than they are wrong.

Nate Throm, Latrobe: Why does Pirates management have this fixation with “resting players,” even if it costs them games?

Zeise: It isn’t just the Pirates management. It is Major League Baseball in general. The Pirates probably take it to the extreme, but every team rests players regularly. Every team has its own plan for resting players. Every team reads the same data and has the same access to analytics. The Pirates aren’t any different from most teams. The difference is the Pirates are chasing a playoff berth right now and should be playing their best players every night. Let the off days be the ones built into the schedule.

Albert Betts, Pittsburgh: How was it determined that Baz was the player to be named later in the Archer deal? I know they said it would be a significant player, but throwing in your No. 1 draft pick from last year into the deal seems a bit steep.

Zeise: It is usually a pool of a couple of players to choose from and the team decides which one fits their needs best. That’s all. The Pirates probably did overpay a little bit for Chris Archer, but that’s the price of doing business in baseball. You want something of value? You have to pay a little more than you want to from time to time. This is how winning franchises operate. I have no issue with the Pirates giving up what they did to get Archer. They needed another starter and they got a good one who is tied up for a couple more years.

Advertise with us

Kirk Diggler, @pghjoker: How do you let your star quarterback get hit and sustain a concussion in practice?

Zeise: It happens from time to time. It wasn’t about letting Ben Roethlisberger get hit. You have 280-300-plus-pound defensive linemen and fast linebackers and you are in a live drill. It can be hard for them to pull up all the way before contact. In this case it wasn’t like he got hit hard, just enough to knock him off balance. It happens, and it sounds like he will be fine. You can’t get a defense ready for the season if they aren’t able to play at full speed during practice.

Dac, @Dac00272734: Is Ben fragile or what?

Zeise: You mean because he’s in the concussion protocol after getting hit? No. He is actually one of the tougher quarterbacks in the league. Think about how many hits that guy has endured throughout his career. He is tough, he keeps coming back, he absorbs hits, he plays with injuries. There are a lot of things you can question about Roethlisberger, but his toughness is not one of them.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com

Advertise with us

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.