James Harrison went on FS1’s “Undisputed” and said some mean things about Mike Tomlin.
He said Tomlin isn’t as good as Bill Belichick, Tomlin needs more discipline, and Tomlin plays favorites. This caused a bit of a stir with some Steelers fans and those who staunchly defend Tomlin.
Harrison was once a beloved Steelers player and considered one of the all-time greats. That all changed when he forced his way out of town by being disruptive and insubordinate and then he doubled down by signing with the Patriots. It is clear in his comment since that Harrison believed he was lied to by Tomlin about what his role would be when he signed his final contract.
He has an ax to grind with Tomlin and the Steelers and thus his words should be taken with a grain of salt. That’s, at least, how some people have attempted to dismiss what Harrison said. It is a neat and convenient way to dismiss Harrison’s comments, but the fact that he comes off as petty doesn’t mean he is wrong.
Belichick is a better coach than Tomlin. He is also a better coach than everyone else currently coaching football on the planet as well as pretty much every other coach that has ever stood on an NFL sideline. He is one of the greatest coaches ever, so it isn’t like Harrison is going out on a limb with that assertion. Only a fool would argue Tomlin is a better coach than Belichick, but if the worst thing you can say about Tomlin is that he isn’t as good as one of the greatest of all time, he is doing just fine.
That isn’t really a criticism of Tomlin, though, it is Harrison’s way of taking a shot at him. The part about a lack of discipline, however, isn’t completely wrong. Tomlin needs to run a tighter ship. That doesn’t mean he has to adopt draconian laws and forms of punishment like Belichick does (at least according to Harrison), but he does need to end some of the foolishness that seemingly always surrounds the Steelers.
Read More
The Steelers should have been to a Super Bowl in the past four seasons and they haven’t been. They have one AFC title game appearance in four years despite having the best trio of quarterback, running back and receiver in the NFL. They are 45-19 and have three division titles in that span, but they are only 3-4 in the playoffs. Twice in those four years they lost at home in their first playoff game and only once have they been knocked out by the Patriots.
There are plenty of reasons why the Steelers have been underachievers the past four years. They have had a porous defense. Their stars haven’t played well enough at times. They have been outplayed or physically manhandled, like last year in their loss to Jacksonville. They have had some injuries, though the Philadelphia Eagles proved this year that great teams can overcome key injuries to win a Super Bowl.
That’s why to say a lack of discipline — or lack of attention to detail — is the sole reason for their recent underwhelming playoff performances is a bit of a stretch. It isn’t wrong, though, to argue that all of the off-field distractions, ridiculous locker room controversies and lack of player accountability has contributed to those losses.
The Steelers never seem to be a focused team, at least not a team that is focused on the right things. There always seems to be something beyond football going on with the Steelers. Some of that noise is unavoidable but some of it could be wiped out if Tomlin was more proactive about it.
He could have reeled in Antonio Brown and Le’Veon Bell at times, he could have stepped in earlier with Harrison, and he could have pulled Ben Roethlisberger and Todd Haley into his office and told them both to grow up when they were taking passive-aggressive shots at each other in the media, but he didn’t. He rarely stepped in publicly, and considering the team never seemed to get focused on the right things, he probably didn’t do it behind closed doors, either.
Tomlin is an excellent coach and he has, for the most part, done a good job with the Steelers. He has underachieved in the past four seasons, though, and while there are many reasons, Harrison may be on to something when comparing the ship he runs to that of Belichick.
The Patriots seem to be focused on football and winning games, and that is the tone set by Belichick. Tomlin could absolutely get better in this area and needs to or the Steelers’ playoff run will end abruptly and too early for the fifth year in a row.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.