The Pirates are either the dumbest MLB organization or are simply out-thinking themselves. I can’t figure out which fits better, but their decisions in recent weeks have me leaning towards the former.

Gregory Polanco and Sean Rodriguez weren’t in the Pirates’ lineup Monday night. That’s smart. Polanco is a bad fielder who is hitting barely above the Mendoza line, and Rodriguez is hitting .162. It should be a no-brainer that neither of those two players gets to start with any degree of regularity.

The Pirates’ best three outfielders at this point, by a wide margin, are Starling Marte, Austin Meadows and Corey Dickerson. All three are far superior to Polanco in the field and at the plate. Rodriguez is the worst (non-pitcher) hitter for the Pirates this year. He should be a defensive replacement late in games, an occasional pinch-hitter and nothing else.

Monday was only the third time in 23 games since Meadows was recalled that neither Polanco nor Rodriguez were in the starting lineup. Over that same span, the Pirates have had both Polanco and Rodriguez in the lineup as many times (three) as they have played with neither.

Advertise with us

That means the Pirates have put an inferior lineup on the field 20 times in the past 23 games. That number bumps up to 21 out of 23 when you consider they had David Freese in the lineup Monday instead of Colin Moran.

Freese, who bats righthanded, was in the lineup because the Diamondbacks had a lefty on the mound. That makes sense, except Moran (.238/.407/.286, with a .694 OPS) actually is hitting lefties better than Freese (.200/.269/.222, with a .491 OPS). Freese is a better fielder than Moran, but that gap is not nearly wide enough to justify starting him.

I’m sure the Pirates have all kinds of numbers to justify their lineups. I’m sure they believe the lineup they put out every night gives them the best chance to win.

The problem is that they aren’t winning, and that’s the only number that should matter. Meadows made his debut May 18 against San Diego, and the Pirates were 26-17. They are now 32-34, which means they’re 6-17 in the 23 games since Meadows was recalled. That’s, in part, due to the bullpen, which has been a disaster lately, but the Pirates also haven’t put their best team on the field for 21 of those games.

There may not be an answer to the bullpen problems, but one could already be on the team. How about Joe Musgrove, who was an excellent reliever last season for the Astros, or Chad Kuhl, who has one of the best arms on the team and skills that likely would make him an extremely effective reliever?

Advertise with us

The Pirates have other options for their rotation now that Ivan Nova is back. Jameson Taillon, Trevor Williams, Nova and Nick Kingham should be four of the five Pirates starters. The fifth should be either Kuhl or Musgrove, and the odd man out should help shore up the bullpen. That probably won’t happen, which is why Kingham is in Class AAA Indianapolis, even though he is clearly one of the Pirates’ best 12 pitchers.

The Pirates need to put their best players on their roster and on the field every night and see how far that takes them.

The Pirates, under Neal Huntington, have always been on the cutting edge with analytics. They have made smart decisions in the past and haven’t gotten dumb overnight. They are indeed smart, but right now they might be too smart for their own good. They’re overthinking, and it’s causing them to make bad personnel decisions.