Jameson Taillon hasn’t been anything close to the ace he was supposed to be. Ivan Nova seems to be a couple more bad starts away from either being DFA’d or traded for whatever anyone is willing to give the Pirates. Chad Kuhl is extremely inconsistent and seems to struggle beyond the fifth inning. Steven Brault has already flamed out and is in the bullpen, a role that seems to fit him well.

That’s why Friday night’s starter, Joe Musgrove, is so important to the Pirates’ success this season. He has had shoulder issues that have delayed his arrival to the majors for two months, but he will make his Pirates debut at PNC Park against the St. Louis Cardinals. It is probably too dramatic to say the Pirates’ season hinges on whether Musgrove becomes the pitcher general manager Neal Huntington thinks he can, but that’s actually not that far from the truth. If it isn’t Musgrove, the Pirates would then likely have to look outside the organization for a veteran starter, and they seem to be reluctant to do that at this point.

Musgrove has pitched 17⅔ innings over four minor league rehab starts. He last pitched in a major league game in Game 6 of the World Series for the Astros, but that was as a reliever. He was moved to the bullpen in July after he was ineffective as a starter. His main problem was that he struggled after he got through the opponent’s lineup once. That’s not an ideal way to remain in the rotation, and over 25 career starts he has a 5.37 ERA.

He appeared in 49 games with the Astros. He has an 11-12 record and 4.52 ERA, averaging 8.1 strikeouts per nine innings. He has a strong fastball that averages 93 miles per hour, and his best secondary pitch is a slider. Huntington believes Musgrove, who is only 25, just needs experience and that his effectiveness as a starter will increase with more opportunity.

Advertise with us

That may or may not be the case, but a pitcher at his age with his arm is certainly worth the shot. The Pirates need him to figure it out rather quickly, though, as their margin for error seems to be shrinking. They have lost five of their past six games and are entering a brutal stretch that spans all the way to the All-Star break. They cannot afford to have another young pitcher trying to learn on the job and find himself every time he takes the field.

Musgrove’s success or failure isn’t just a key to the Pirates, it will also determine whether the Pirates got enough in return from the Astros for Gerrit Cole. It, so far, looks like the Pirates at least got two solid major league players in that deal — reliever Michael Feliz and third baseman Colin Moran — but Musgrove, to me, is the key. Starting pitcher was the most glaring hole created by the Cole trade.

If Musgrove becomes a big part of the Pirates rotation over the next three or four seasons — assuming what we have seen from Feliz and Moran isn’t a mirage —  the Cole trade will become Huntington’s best.

There is a long way between now and then, though, and Musgrove needs to first prove he can stay healthy enough to remain in the rotation. The next step would then be for him to prove he can be consistent enough. If he is able to do both, it will go a long way towards shoring up the Pirates rotation. It seems like only a matter of time before Taillon figures it out, and Trevor Williams has been the team’s best and most consistent pitcher.

Musgrove would then give the Pirates a third reliable starter. That would be a great step towards the Pirates building the pitching staff Huntington envisioned when he made the Cole trade in the offseason.