The Pirates are off to a strong start, but if they want to finish the season as a contender they still need one more starting pitcher. It was an obvious need before the season, and 46 games later it hasn’t changed. The Pirates have a lot of young arms in their system but don’t have enough who are ready to be regular starters on a contending team.

Trevor Williams has been the team’s best starting pitcher this season. That shouldn’t be much of a surprise given his work last season, and he has a bright future. Jameson Taillon has been wildly inconsistent and hasn’t quite lived up to his billing as the staff ace. He has too much talent, though, so it should come together here soon and he will begin to pitch consistently well.

Those are the only two starters the Pirates can feel good about the rest of the season. The other three spots are a real question right now, and that’s why the team’s early success doesn’t feel sustainable. The Pirates have too many young pitchers they are trying to juggle and all of them will struggle with consistency — or worse — as the long season wears on.

The one experienced pitcher the Pirates do have, Ivan Nova, is slightly below average (career 1.35 WHIP, 4.28 FIP, 4.30 ERA, 98 ERA+). There are some signs the Pirates should be a little concerned that he is their third starter. He has given up 16 earned runs in his past four starts (18.1 IP), and his ERA is 4.79 after 10 starts.

Advertise with us

The fourth and fifth spots in the rotation have been manned by Chad Kuhl, Steven Brault and Nick Kingham. All three are 26 and younger, so it isn’t a surprise all three have struggled with consistency. That isn’t likely to change, and Brault has already been moved into the bullpen.

Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.

Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.

Kuhl is 4-2, but his numbers (1.39 WHIP, 4.53 ERA, .237 opponents’ batting average) suggest his win-loss record isn’t an accurate barometer of how he has pitched. He has gotten beyond six innings only once in nine starts, and his ERA has not been below 4.00 all season. Kingham has started only three games, with mixed results. His first start was excellent, his second and third were not. That doesn’t mean he isn’t capable of being a starter, it means he is young and inconsistent.

The Pirates can afford to have either Kuhl or Kingham in their rotation but having both, given Nova’s profile, will be a lot to overcome to contend for the National League Central Division title. It is possible for a team to overcome one inconsistent starter but overcoming three is not realistic. Teams can hide flaws and deficiencies over smaller sample sizes but not an entire season.

Advertise with us

That’s why the Pirates need one more starter. They need to stabilize the rotation and build it for the long haul. That’s also why they should be looking for an experienced starter, one that isn’t likely to have so many ups and downs.

They do still have Joe Musgrove, and he will start Friday. Maybe he is the answer, but I’m guessing he won’t be. He, too, is young, doesn’t have much experience and has been wildly inconsistent in Class AAA so far. He was an excellent reliever in Houston last year but struggled as a starter.

The Pirates do have a chance to contend at least for a wild card this year. I’m convinced their offense is sustainable because they don’t have any obvious weakness in their everyday lineup. The additions of Corey Dickerson and Colin Moran and the return to form of Starling Marte and Francisco Cervelli have bolstered the lineup and made the Pirates a dangerous offensive club.

That all could be for naught, though, if the pitching fails to deliver for the long run. The Pirates have the start of a strong rotation but are relying on too many young, inconsistent pitchers. They need one more starter, and then they will become an easy team to believe in.