Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. This feature will run each Wednesday, so you have a whole week to submit questions.
Let’s get started:
Chad Ruffner, New Alexandria: If you were Kevin Colbert, who would you take with the Steelers 1st round draft pick?
Zeise: I think they should draft an inside linebacker. That has to be the priority. They need depth there. I know they have Jon Bostic, but he is an often-injured player who needs an insurance policy. If one of the top inside linebackers is not on the board, then they need to go safety. It would be interesting if Lamar Jackson is still on the board. I don’t know if I would have the guts to take him but I would certainly be tempted to. He is such a talented player and could be such a difference maker down the road. The other intriguing position would be running back. That would allow me to have some options with Le’Veon Bell. I fully believe, though, that Kevin Colbert and company will go linebacker in the first round because it’s the position they need to fill the most.
Nate Thorm: Why do you think some people feel that Clint Hurdle is a good manager? He's had 4 winning seasons vs 11 losing seasons on 2 teams in his managerial career. That in no way is good.
Zeise: It’s hard to evaluate managers based on record. Hurdle has shown he can get teams to overachieve, as he did in Colorado and in Pittsburgh from 2013-15. He does good work with younger players. He seems to get the most out of his bench, and players seem to respect and play hard for him. At the end of last year, when morale was low, they were still trying to compete. He does do some things that drive you crazy, especially with regards to how he handles the pitchers, but no manager is perfect. Given that Hurdle’s strengths are working with younger players and interchangeable parts, he is the perfect manager for a small-market team like the Pirates.
Devidid Woods: Do you think that the cost of youth and amateur sports (AAU, travel baseball, speed and agility) is financially out of hand? I understand that markets are set by what consumers are willing to pay. I feel that the thousands used on these recreational activities typically don't end in a D1 or most times even D3.
Zeise: Players who want to play at a higher level and legitimately have a future as college prospects should. There is nothing wrong with it. I would also say that playing in a club sport probably does increase your chances of even playing and competing at the Division III level. That being said, yes, the price tag of some of it is out of hand, and there are too many unrealistic parents out there who will pay anything for the dream of their kid getting recruited. The problem with club/AAU sports isn’t the players who need to compete at a higher level, the problem is there are too many players who have no realistic shot at being much more than a Division III player (if that), and those are the ones who get taken advantage of.
James Sattel, @newportrisites1: Sutherland and pop warner... have bigger than life names, yet I don’t think that their association with PITT has been duly recognized, within the school, locally, and nationalIy I think it would be great if we did more to reflect and promote their association with our university
Zeise: I disagree. They are prominently displayed in the South Side facility. When my son was recruited, their association with the school was explained in great detail by the assistant coach, Bob Junko, who took us around on the campus tour.
Marty Fercio, New Castle: The Penguins always beat the Capitals so what would make anyone think this year would be any different? The Penguins will get inside Braden Holtby’s head like usual. I say the Penguins in 5, what about you?
Zeise: This is a sentiment that isn’t without merit. I do think five games is a bit aggressive, but I expect the Penguins to win in seven. They have Braden Holtby figured out, and that will be the difference. The Penguins are also faster than the Capitals, and the Capitals’ stars always seem to come up small in the biggest games of the season.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.