The Penguins are 9-1 in playoff series against the Capitals and have beaten them in each of the past two postseasons. That history will be a primary reason most people will pick the Penguins to win the Eastern Conference semifinals, which begin this week.

That’s a neat little narrative, but it isn’t relevant to this series.

I believe the Penguins will win in six games, but not because they have a mental edge. No, it will be because they have Matt Murray, one of the best playoff goaltenders in NHL history. Like most playoff series, this will come down to goaltending, and Capitals goalie Braden Holtby can’t outplay Murray four times in seven games.

Murray is 26-11 in playoff games, has the 13th best playoff goals against average (1.99) and is tied for 10th in playoff save percentage (.926). He has won two Stanley Cups and has a propensity for playing his best games when the Penguins need it most.

Advertise with us

Holtby was benched for the start of the Capitals’ first-round series against Columbus because he struggled to end the regular season. Holtby came into Game 2 when Philipp Grubauer was beat for four goals on 22 shots. He finished that game strong and was given his starting job back. He was mostly spectacular as the Capitals won four games in a row. His playoff numbers, outside of his record (33-31), are very similar to Murray’s (1.99 goals against average, .932 save percentage).

The Penguins chased Holtby out of the game Feb. 2 in a 7-4 win, but Holtby stopped 27 of 28 shots Nov. 10 in a 4-1 Capitals win — his 200th win in 319 career games. He’s the second-fastest goaltender in NHL history to get to 200 wins. So, he’s more than capable of leading the Capitals to a win in this series.

There are other factors that come into play when trying to predict a winner. It’s fairly simple, though. It will come down to which team gets the better play from its goaltender. That’s why I’m picking the Penguins to win. Holtby will have his moments, but there won’t be nearly enough of them.