Bud Dupree is entering his fourth season with the Steelers and so far his body of work has been somewhat underwhelming. Dupree has shown some flashes of his potential but has not been nearly as consistent as a first-round pick needs to be at this point in his career.

The Steelers were facing a tough choice this offseason with regard to picking up his fifth-year option. Dupree has been inconsistent and has had a propensity for disappearing for long stretches of games.

He was drafted to be a high-impact player who makes game-changing plays and he has not delivered in that area.

Dupree hasn’t, however, been a total bust like 2013 first-round pick Jarvis Jones - who they did not offer the option to - and thus the Steelers made the right call in offering him a fifth-year option.

Advertise with us

Dupree hasn’t been a superstar or anything close to this point, but he has done enough good things that suggest he could be poised for a breakout season. He has also been a bit unfairly criticized for his lack of production with regard to sacks because he is dropping into coverage more than the Steelers’ previous outside linebackers, whose primary job was to rush the quarterback.

The Steelers have essentially said they still believe in Dupree, and they are making sure they can keep him beyond this season when his original rookie contract expires. There is also very little risk involved in the fifth-year option for the Steelers. They are on the hook for $9 million for next season in the event Dupree is injured this season and cannot play in 2019 and that isn’t likely to happen.

It is true that the Steelers are on the hook for $8.7 million for Ryan Shazier in 2019, but he suffered a bit of a freak injury. It is true that players are injured often in football, but it isn’t particularly often that players suffer an injury in one season that keeps them out the entire next season. The Steelers exercised the fifth-year option on Shazier because they wanted to buy some time to negotiate a long-term deal.

That has been the way they have generally operated with their first-round picks since 2011, when the current collective bargaining agreement went into effect. The significant change for this current deal was that teams could provide an option year for any of their first-round picks that is fully guaranteed for injury.

The Steelers have made seven first-round draft picks since the fifth-year option became available to them. Artie Burns (2015) and T.J. Watt (2016) have not played long enough yet to be considered for it. Dupree is eligible for it this offseason.

Advertise with us

That means there have been four players the Steelers have had to make this decision on, and Jones is the only one they didn’t pick up the option on.

The other three are Shazier (2014), Cameron Heyward (2011) and David DeCastro (2012), and the Steelers exercised the fifth-year option on all three. The Steelers then negotiated a long-term deal with Heyward and DeCastro prior to their fifth season. They likely would have done the same with Shazier had he not been injured in a game against the Bengals in Cincinnati last season.

I would be shocked if the Steelers offered Dupree a long-term deal until after the season. They want to see whether he plays like a first-round draft pick in his fourth season should play. And that is the beauty of this move to pick up his fifth-year option — if he doesn’t play well they can rescind it at the end of this season.

That’s why there is no real downside for the Steelers except in the case that Dupree suffers a major injury. If he has a big year, they know they have him for at least 2019, and if he doesn’t they can move on from him without penalty. Dupree could be a bust, but he could also have a breakout season and go out and get a bunch of sacks and the Steelers seem content to wait and see.

Dupree’s natural talent and athleticism are easy to see. His speed, first-step quickness and ability to get to the quarterback all suggest he has the tools to be a star. He looks the part and from time to time he has played the part as well. The Steelers have seen enough from him that they are hedging their bets, but at very little risk and relatively low cost. It is clearly the best move they could have made because even if they can’t sign him long-term, they can at least control him for 2019 before they lose him.