Heather Lyke is one of four female athletic directors in Power Five conferences. She hired a man, Lance White, to lead the Pitt women’s basketball program, and her decision has been criticized by some.
I’ve heard from many members of the women’s basketball community who are unhappy with the hire. That isn’t shocking because the desire to find more opportunities for women coaches has always been a fight in women’s basketball. Lyke joined the good ol’ boys club of athletic directors, and thus there is disappointment by some that she didn’t in turn provide a woman with an opportunity to take the Power Five job she had to offer.
Victoria Brownworth, an investigative journalist who writes for the Huffington Post and used to write for the Baltimore Sun and Philadelphia Inquirer, shared her stance via Twitter:
In all of America #Pitt was unable to find a single woman qualified to coach women.
— Victoria Brownworth (@VABVOX) April 18, 2018
I wonder how many women were on the search committee?#LanceWhite https://t.co/IDqjJcW9nE
Brownworth obviously didn’t do her homework because the search committee was led by a woman (Lyke) and Bethany Wagner, the women’s basketball administrator at Pitt, is also a woman. Still, Brownworth’s overall point is shared by many.
White, like Jeff Capel, whom Lyke hired a few weeks ago to lead the men’s program, has an excellent resume. He helped lead Florida State to 12 20-win seasons in the past 15 years and was the Women's Basketball Coaches Association National Assistant Coach of the Year for 2016-17.
It isn’t easy to hire basketball coaches at Pitt because it isn’t an easy job, especially in the ACC. The women’s program has just four NCAA appearances and four WNIT appearances since 1982, when it joined the Big East. More recently, the Panthers are 30-99 in conference games over the past nine seasons.
Lyke understands this, and that’s why she went out and found a coach like White with a track record of success working in a Power Five program. White was at Florida State since 2003 and was at Texas Tech before that. Like Capel, he has a recruited ACC players for a top ACC program and has a track record of success in the ACC’s geographic footprint.
Recruiting is the most important part of coaching in a power conference, and Lyke is the first Pitt athletic director who seems to understand this. It is nice to take a chance on an up-and-comer, but if you want to win in the ACC, you better hire someone who can bring in ACC players.
Suzie McConnell-Serio is brilliant at X’s and O’s, but she failed here because she didn’t recruit well enough. Her ability to scheme was mitigated by the fact that most of the coaches she had to beat had much better players.
Lyke shouldn’t be subject to criticism; she should be celebrated for trying to put Pitt’s women’s basketball program in the best position to win.
There has been a real struggle over the course of time by many to get universities to stop treating women’s basketball programs as second-class citizens. The fact that Lyke hired a male coach is not an affront to that struggle; it is an enhancement. I can’t imagine White came cheap or without assurances that he’d have full support of the administration to build his program. That shows the school is committed to winning in women’s basketball.
Lyke didn’t shun equality in hiring White; if anything, she embraced it. She didn’t worry about the color or sex of the coach she hired. She went out and hired who she decided was the best person for the job for the second time in a month.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.