The Pirates are off to a flying start, and there are some signs it may not be a fluke.
That doesn’t mean they’ll likely contend for the National League Central Division title, but they may be able hang around the wild-card race until deep into the season.
Corey Dickerson has solidified their outfield and lineup. Colin Moran has, at least to this point, proved to be a solid addition, as well. Jameson Taillon and Trevor Williams appear to be a strong 1-2 punch at the top of the rotation. Starling Marte appears to be back to what he was in 2016. Middle relief has been an issue, but Neal Huntington always seems to be able to find bullpen arms, so I’m assuming that will be fixed at some point.
All of those things suggest the Pirates have a chance to be better than most of their projections. Their rotation needs to improve, though. One more starter would go a long way toward solving their middle relief issues, as well.
The Pirates’ next-best pitcher behind Taillon and Williams, Ivan Nova, is probably a back-of-the-rotation pitcher at best. Chad Kuhl and Steven Brault are probably best-suited in the bullpen as middle relievers who occasionally start. Both are young and could improve, but even the most optimistic projections show them as solid back-end starters.
The Pirates need to figure out if any of their internal options are capable of filling the middle-rotation starter void sooner rather than later. The internal options start with Tyler Glasnow. He has had mixed results in the bullpen this season, which seems to be the story of his career. Joe Musgrove should be next up because he has high-level stuff. The best-case scenario would be for Musgrove and Glasnow to stay in the rotation and Brault and Kuhl bolster the bullpen. If that doesn’t work, there’s Nick Kingham, who is 1-0 in Indianapolis with an 0.82 ERA and a 0.64 WHIP (walks plus hits per inning pitched).
If all of those internal options, fail, the Pirates need to find an external option via trade. If they have to overpay a little to get that pitcher, they need to do it. This team has shown some signs of competency, so the front office needs to put its money where its mouth is and provide the help the Pirates need in order to have a legitimate chance at the postseason.
That may be easier said than done, but the Pirates probably are one more legitimate middle-of-the-rotation starter from having a chance to be a legitimate wild-card contender. The front office often talks about wanting to put a winner on the field. Well, here’s the chance to earn some credibility.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.