The Pirates have won their first four games. Their next task is to win fans back.
If Monday’s crowd — the smallest for a home opener in PNC Park history — is any indication, that second task could take some time.
At least 60,000 fans expressed their loss of faith in the form of a petition to remove Bob Nutting as owner. They are tired of an organization that seems happy to hover around .500 and annually sells off all of its stars. Nutting is in his 11th season as owner, so the sample size isn’t small anymore. He has fielded 10 teams, and only three have had a winning record.
The Pirates front office continually tries to sell the idea that a World Series is its goal. Their actions generally say something different. The Pirates may be trying to win, but there is a legitimate question as to what their definition of winning actually is.
They won a lot of games between 2013-15 but never stretched themselves to try to get all the way over the top. That’s one huge difference between the Astros and Pirates. The Astros stripped down their roster to basically prospects and rookies a few years back and began the process of rebuilding. They won the World Series last season.
A lot of people try to justify the Pirates’ offseason by saying they basically did a lesser version of what the Astros did. They are rebuilding with younger players and have a lot of their best young players under contract for a number of years. The theory is they will all grow up together, and in a couple of years, the Pirates will be contenders again.
Read More
That may be true, but there is a major difference between what the Astros did and what the Pirates are likely to do. The Astros did strip down and rebuild, but when they got to the point where it looked like they would compete, they added millions of dollars in veterans to fill in the roster over the past two years. Then, they acquired Justin Verlander (who makes $28 million) last August in order to get themselves over the top.
The Pirates didn’t ever stretch themselves, and they let that window of opportunity with Andrew McCutchen slip away.
Will the Pirates add the necessary pieces to this group? Will they spend the money to go get that one superstar who is the final piece of the puzzle, like Verlander was for the Astros?
Until the Pirates can begin to provide answers, fans will remain skeptical. Ultimately, fans will come back if the Pirates win games, but it won’t happen overnight. The Pirates front office is going to have to prove itself again.
This season is still too early for the skeptics to believe it isn’t a mirage. The Pirates will need to continue to win and continue to play exciting baseball, and if they do, fans will fill up PNC Park again, at least for the weekend games.
Until then, though, there will be more poorly attended games — and that’s not necessarily a bad thing if it gets the front office’s attention. It’s one thing for the front office to say it wants to win a World Series, but it’s something completely different to do the things necessary to put a team on the field that is capable of winning it all.
Pirates fans reflect on opening day: 'We love the team. We love the game.'





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.