The start of a baseball season always brings hope. There are many Pirates fans, however, who believe there is no hope this year. It has been a rough offseason, and fan apathy seems to be as high as it has been for quite some time.

Things are so bad for the Pirates, at least in perception, that Frank Coonelly and Neal Huntington have had more meet-and-greet luncheons with fans than usual. The goal is for them to listen to fans and reassure them that they are indeed trying to win the World Series.

As much as I want to believe this team is young, energetic and hungry, I just can’t see it as a contender. There just isn’t a logical case to be made that this team is going to be markedly better than last year’s team — and that team won only 75 games.

The argument that this team might shock the world revolves around Gregory Polanco, Starling Marte, Jameson Taillon, Francisco Cervilli and Ivan Nova having bounce-back or career years.

Advertise with us

It requires us to believe Marte will have more power off the juice than he did when he was on it. It requires us to believe Polanco is the player he was billed to be and not the player he has been. It also requires us to believe that Cervelli is not going to be the injury-prone catcher who can’t throw runners out.

Taillon is ready to take the next step and be this staff’s ace. The only issue with him is, like Cervelli, he has had a hard time staying healthy, and that has hindered his development.

Colin Moran and Corey Dickerson are the obvious wild cards. Dickerson has a reasonable track record as a bona fide major league hitter, but he isn’t a good fielder and slumped badly in the second half of last season. Moran is billed as this power hitter who will hit 20-25 homers, but he has a grand total of 11 MLB at-bats. Moran and Dickerson will be closer to “slightly above average” than standout players or stars.

This doesn’t even account for the Pirates being one of the worst defensive teams in the National League.

The starting rotation has too many questions facing it, as well. We are supposed to believe this rotation, with Joe Musgrove instead of Gerrit Cole, has somehow improved. We are supposed to view Chad Kuhl as a dynamic middle-of-the-rotation pitcher and believe Musgrove will finally arrive.

Advertise with us

It is possible all of that is true, but it isn’t logical. Ivan Nova has been a very average pitcher for almost his entire career, Kuhl seems to be closer to a back-of-the-rotation pitcher and Musgrove struggled as a starter last season. Maybe one of those three has a breakout season and proves critics wrong, but it would be almost unprecedented if all three did. Tyler Glasnow had some flashes in the spring but still has a long way to go to prove it wasn’t all a mirage.

The bullpen should be stronger than it was last year, but that is about the only area in which this year’s team is definitely better than last year’s team.

All of these things could come together for the Pirates, and maybe they do shock the world. Maybe the front office really does know what it is doing and everyone else is too blind to see the talent on this team. I’m willing to have an open mind and believe this team could contend, but I have serious doubts about that — and clearly so do most of their fans.