The Pirates starting rotation has so many unknowns that it is impossible to try and even project just how good it will be. And by extension, that means it is nearly impossible to project how many games the Pirates will win or even the range of wins they will be in. The Pirates have a lot of pitchers with large questions hovering over them, and that generally isn’t a good sign headed into a season.
That doesn’t mean the Pirates rotation is necessarily going to be bad, though. It just means that a lot is going to have to go right for the staff to carry the team into contention. That’s why it is hard for me to believe this team is going to win much more than 77-78 games, but there are enough intriguing pieces in place to at least entertain the thought.
Jameson Taillon is now the ace of the staff. Taillon is cool, calm, collected and a bit cocky, and that’s how he takes the mound. We have seem him at his best, we just haven’t seen it consistently. We also haven’t seen him get through an entire season healthy, and that has to be a concern. Taillon showed glimpses of the pitcher the Pirates are hoping he can be in 2016 when he went 104 innings in 18 starts and had an ERA of 3.38, an ERA+ of 123 and a 1.15 WHIP. Those numbers slid last season (4.44, 97 and 1.48), but he battled testicular cancer. He should be fully healthy now, and the hope is he bounces back to form.
Ivan Nova is probably for now the Pirates’ No. 2 pitcher. If Nova is the pitcher the Pirates had from when they acquired him at the 2016 trade deadline until about the All-Star break last season, they have an excellent pitcher in the No. 2 slot. However, if he is the pitcher he was in the second half of last season, or throughout most of his career, for that matter, they have an average pitcher who projects more as a No. 4 or even No. 5 starter than anything else. Nova has a career WHIP of 1.35, an ERA+ of 99 and 4.27 ERA.
The one pitcher in the rotation that seems to be a known quantity is Trevor Williams, who had a solid rookie season in 2017. Williams was probably the Pirates’ most consistent pitcher, and while his numbers didn’t light the world on fire (4.07 ERA, ERA+ 106 and WHIP 1.31) he pitched well for a rookie. Williams doesn’t have elite stuff but has shown he can get major league hitters out consistently.
Chad Kuhl is going to likely be No. 4 in the rotation, and I’m not sure how to feel about it. If Kuhl indeed has worked on some of his secondary pitches, can harbor his emotions a little better and improve on his innings pitched per outing, then he is capable of being a solid back-of-the-rotation pitcher. If he is the Chad Kuhl we saw last year, a wildly inconsistent (1.42 WHIP, 4.31 ERA, ERA+ 99) pitcher who struggled to get through the batting order two times, he will need to be replaced.
The fifth spot in the rotation is, like with most teams, a complete unknown. Every option seems to have the potential for feast or famine. Joe Musgrove throws in the high 90s and has some potential but has already had some shoulder issues. He was also much better last season in Houston in the bullpen than he was as a starter. Steven Brault looks more like a solid spot starter than a full-time starter. Tyler Glasnow has more potential than anyone, maybe, on the staff, but he was mostly a disaster last season. Nick Kingham has also had arm issues in the past, but like Glasnow and Musgrove, he has a high ceiling.
The best-case scenario is that Musgrove and Glasnow pan out and push Kuhl into the bullpen. But the Pirates only need one of those two to pan out in order to have a solid fifth starter.
It’s hard to project the Pirates as a playoff contender based on these questions, but they do have enough talented options to believe they can get a solid start almost every night out. That’s the best Pirates fans can hope for. While it seems a like a bit much to ask, it isn’t impossible and may not even be as improbable as it seems.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.