The fair thing to do would be for Pitt to give Kevin Stallings more time to build the basketball program. It isn’t a popular opinion, and indications are that isn’t likely to happen. When addressing the state of the program last month, athletic director Heather Lyke didn’t even mention Stallings by name.
There are other indications, too, and plenty of rumors that Stallings days are numbered. Beyond that, fans stopped showing up at Petersen Events Center. That is one of Stallings’ biggest problems, as Post-Gazette columnist Joe Starkey so aptly laid out. He also wasn’t hired by Lyke, and that’s not good for a coach on the verge of going 0-fer in conference play.
If indeed these are the final days for Stallings, let’s hope Pitt has learned from mistakes of the past when it comes to finding his replacement. There is far too much at stake this time for the athletic administration to hire the wrong person, again.
Pitt would already be starting out poorly in that regard if it is going to fire a coach after only two seasons. The administration should learn from the football debacle of 2010-2015 that changing coaches like most people change shoes is not a good way to sustain success. Dave Wannstedt had Pitt football contending for Big East titles and averaged nine wins a season his final three years and was fired. That was 2010, and eight years later the program still hasn’t reached that level again.
That’s why there is a strong case to be made that Pitt’s quickest and best path back to respectability is to give Stallings more time. He already has the foundation in place, he has a core of young players to build around and he is an accomplished coach who has proved he can build a program.
Stallings never had a chance, though, as he followed an incredibly successful coach in Jamie Dixon and was viewed as a retread hire even though he had some success at places where it isn’t easy to win. If Pitt fires him, it will be starting from scratch.
Read More
Pitt’s biggest mistake, though, wasn’t hiring Stallings; it was the process, or lack of a process, that led to his hiring. Scott Barnes wanted to make a splash. He zeroed in on Stallings almost immediately and finished the process in about a week. He didn’t take the time to look far and wide to make sure he wasn’t missing the next Ben Howland.
The idea of searching for a big name and not the best basketball coach available is the second mistake Pitt needs to avoid. This stuff about “winning the press conference” to “energize the fan base” is utter nonsense. Howland didn’t win the press conference. Dixon didn’t win the press conference. Todd Graham was the hot name when he was hired here, and he won his press conference. Which of those three coaches didn’t work out?
The football program is seemingly stable again, and Lyke made the right move to give Pat Narduzzi an extension in December. That’s a great first step back toward rebuilding the athletic department’s credibility. The second is making the right hire for the next basketball coach — if Stallings and Pitt do indeed part ways — and that means taking the time to run a thorough, competent search and not being afraid to reach out to people in the industry for guidance.
Howland didn’t just magically appear on Steve Pederson’s radar all those years back; he was brought to him as a viable candidate by someone within the industry. He certainly wasn’t the sexiest of choices, but he is an excellent basketball coach and he quickly won over the fan base by winning a ton of games.
Pitt coaching searches have become a punchline for jokes and the poster child for incompetence, but that has to be in the past. They got it right when they hired Narduzzi; now they need learn from that process and go find the right basketball coach.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.