Jameson Taillon has faced many obstacles in his rise but has overcome them all. He fought through two major surgeries and testicular cancer over the past four years and put himself in position to lead the Pirates pitching staff this season.
The Pirates are not just hoping he is ready to lead their staff, though, they need him to be their ace. There is no realistic path to the Pirates contending that doesn’t include a big season from Taillon. He has to have an ace-like season and he has to be the one they can rely on to stop losing streaks or this will be their third losing season in a row.
Gerrit Cole was one of the best pitchers in baseball in 2015 and mostly underwhelming the past two seasons. He was still the staff’s ace, though, and for all of his struggles last year, he still pitched 203 innings and had 196 strikeouts. The Pirates have had a pitcher throw for 200 or more innings only twice since 2012 and both times it was Cole (2015, 2017).
Cole is gone, and that means the Pirates need someone else to lead the staff, and the most logical candidate is Taillon. He was the No. 2 overall pick in 2010 and the Pirates had visions of Taillon and Cole (the first overall pick in 2011) eventually becoming a dominant one-two punch at the top of their rotation.
It never happened, though, as Taillon’s progress was impeded. The one season Taillon was mostly healthy was 2016, his rookie year, and he showed plenty of promise after being called up in June. Taillon had dominated Class AAA before his call-up and then made 18 starts for the Pirates and was 5-4 and had a 3.38 ERA and 1.12 WHIP. He pitched 104 innings and struck out 85.
He was poised for a breakout in 2017, but it was mostly wiped out when he was diagnosed with testicular cancer. He returned to the mound for the second half of the season and showed some flashes but never quite reached a high level of consistency again.
That’s all behind him now. He is healthy and, by all accounts, in a good place mentally. He appears poised to become the dominant pitcher the Pirates thought he could be when they drafted him.
Taillon throws in the mid-90s and has a wicked curveball. He has four strong pitches he can rely on. He has excellent command and when he is on, he can make life miserable for hitters. In his final start of the season, Taillon led the Pirates to a 4-1 win over Washington as he went seven innings, gave up only four hits and one run, and struck out five.
It isn’t just his stuff, though. Taillon has just enough of that “it” factor the great pitchers all seem to have. It is hard to put a finger of what “it” actually is other than to say it is somewhere in the neighborhood between confident and cocky. Taillon doesn’t get rattled and is far less emotional on the mound than Cole ever has been. He is a fighter whose competitive fires burn hot, and he seems to thrive in pressure situations.
He clearly has what it takes to become an ace, but now the Pirates desperately need him to go out and prove it. This has to be the year Taillon puts it all together and arrives. He has shown flashes in the past but now’s the time for him to pitch at a high level much more consistently.
The Pirates have no other realistic option to be their ace. Tyler Glasnow has ace-like stuff but hasn’t shown anywhere near the mettle or the command to be even a solid rotation piece, much less the ace. Ivan Nova is a solid middle-to-bottom of the rotation pitcher. Trevor Williams is maybe the most consistent pitcher on the staff but has limitations, and there is nobody else who would even be in the discussion.
It is a lot to ask Taillon to carry the burden as the staff ace, but that’s what he was drafted to be. He has the ability to be that, as well. Now that Cole is gone, Taillon has no choice but to step up. The Pirates claim they are going to contend this year, but there is no way that can happen unless Taillon has a big season. This has to be Taillon’s time, and the Pirates need to become Taillon’s team.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.